Dynasty League Football Forum

Which team is better on paper looking at a window of this year and 2018.
TE Premium league.....rules/details in sig below

Team A:

Derek Carr (OAK)
Matthew Stafford (DET)

LeGarrette Blount (PHI)
Robert Kelley (WAS)
Ezekiel Elliott (DAL)
Devontae Booker (DEN)
Jordan Howard (CHI)
Lamar Miller (HOU)

Brandon Marshall (NYG)
Jordy Nelson (GB)
Michael Thomas (NO)
Curtis Samuel (CAR)
Julian Edelman (NE)

Jake Butt (DEN)
Jonnu Smith (TEN)
Kyle Rudolph (MIN)
Eric Ebron (DET)


Team B:

Jameis Winston (TB)

Samaje Perine (WAS)
Jeremy McNichols (TB)
Frank Gore (IND)
Jamaal Charles (DEN)
Charles Sims (TB)
Bilal Powell (NYJ)

Golden Tate (DET)
Brandin Cooks (NE)
Corey Davis (TEN)
Cooper Kupp (LA)
Taywan Taylor (TEN)
Amari Cooper (OAK)
Corey Coleman (CLE)
Malcolm Mitchell (NE)

Zach Ertz (PHI)
Tyler Eifert (CIN)
C.J. Fiedorowicz (HOU)
Ladarius Green (PIT)

Fairly even, but I'd lean towards A if I was forced to pick one.

QBs are a push to me between Carr and Winston. Team A has much better RBs, but Team B has better WRs and better TEs. I will take team B but it's mostly because I like Davis, Coleman, Cooper and Cooks quite a bit. It's pretty even tho.

Gotta go A due to the rb position..Its just that much stronger, B has better young wrs, but A has good enough wrs with jordy, thomas, and edelman, te's little stronger on B, but A's aren't bad, qbs are about a wash

Team A by a large margin.

I like Team A better. I like Carr more than Winston and love Team A's RBs.

A for me. Has more studs.

Qb's about a wash slight edge to A, I don't think the WR's are that far behind on A, I don't like the rb situation on B at all, & the better B te's are simply not enough to swing the vote for me.

A for me.

Team A significantly for me.

A by a lot for the short term (since that is your question)

Team B has a gaping hole at RB with essentially zero starters unless Gore can keep his job and Perine can earn his. This is truly a "zero" RB strategy at it's finest.

Voted A by a decent amount.

Team A Has solid RBs, but I'll go with Team B, who has great WRs. The QBs are basically a wash. Both should be top 5 Dynasty QBs for the next 5+ years. A WR core of Cooper, Cooks, Davis and Coleman sounds pretty awesome! Plus team B has the better TE in Eifert over Ebron. So I'll be in the minority here and take team B.

Team A pretty easily! Probably the first thing I would look to do is shop RB capital to add a young wide receiver prospect to eventually replace Marshall and Nelson.

skip wrote: ↑Mon May 22, 2017 9:13 pm Team B has a gaping hole at RB with essentially zero starters unless Gore can keep his job and Perine can earn his. This is truly a "zero" RB strategy at it's finest.

Voted A by a decent amount.

X2

I'll also add that I like the WRs on team A better than team B. Call me crazy.

lukkynumber13 wrote: ↑Mon May 22, 2017 11:52 pm

skip wrote: ↑Mon May 22, 2017 9:13 pm Team B has a gaping hole at RB with essentially zero starters unless Gore can keep his job and Perine can earn his. This is truly a "zero" RB strategy at it's finest.

Voted A by a decent amount.

X2

I'll also add that I like the WRs on team A better than team B. Call me crazy.

I wasn't going to post as I thought I would be the only one who though this. Yeah, in the immediate future, I like team A WRs better. If the question would have been regarding a window of 3+ years, then my WR opinion would be different.