Dynasty League Football Forum

Took over a team and am hurting at RB with Lewis, Marshall, Thompson, Burkhead, Watson, J. Williams.

I got the offer of my Kelvin Benjamin, Doing Lewis and Higbee for Rodgers & either Ingram or D. Murray.

My other WRs are OBJ, ARob, Jeffery, Shepard, Boyd, Sharpe so not too bad there. I already have Winston and Tyrod and I've been trying to move one to see if I can land something and this league does not value it's QBs highly (rightfully so).

With that said the value is there for me right? And if so do I go Ingram or DeMarco Murray?

After a couple days negotiation the final offer is;

KB / Lewis / Higbee / 2.12

for

Rodgers / Ingram / CJA

I would pass on that deal. Look for a better back

I would prefer Lewis over Ingram next year. I think trading KB for Arod is a good trade if you can get it done, with out the Lewis/Ingram swap.

grooner wrote: ↑Tue Jan 17, 2017 7:12 am I would prefer Lewis over Ingram next year. I think trading KB for Arod is a good trade if you can get it done, with out the Lewis/Ingram swap.

Agreed with this
I'd do the trade as is if you have to in order to get Rodgers. If you can get away with a straight up Kelvin for Rodgers, that's better.

I'm on the opposite side it seems...give me Aaron Rodgers and Ingram all day/every day at the price of KBenj and D Lewis

I don't see mention of what 1st round picks this new team might have, but getting Ingram to start the overhaul of the RB position and Rodgers at QB is a win IMO

that one guy wrote: ↑Tue Jan 17, 2017 7:56 am I'm on the opposite side it seems...give me Aaron Rodgers and Ingram all day/every day at the price of KBenj and D Lewis

I don't see mention of what 1st round picks this new team might have, but getting Ingram to start the overhaul of the RB position and Rodgers at QB is a win IMO

I'm working with the other owner to make it KB & Higbee for Rodgers & Ingram. This was a startup draft and the team I took over ended up with rookie pick 1.12. But I feel like the addition of Ingram and the ability to move Winston+ for a RB after may be a good start in improving this team.

0crush83 wrote: ↑Tue Jan 17, 2017 6:29 am I got the offer of my Kelvin Benjamin, Doing Lewis and Higbee for Rodgers & either Ingram or D. Murray.

With that said the value is there for me right?

Doing Lewis -- the ever-present tease.

I'd make this trade all. Day. Long. I'd prefer Ingram.

I want the Ingram side of this deal and to me I wouldn't think twice about it. Snap Accept.

Take Rodgers and Ingram IMO

After a couple days negotiation the final offer is;

KB / Lewis / Higbee / 2.12

for

Rodgers / Ingram / CJA

I think I am going to take that. It helps my RB situation, leaves me with good WRs and improves my QB situation. Then I can trade Winston to help myself in another area. Thanks for everyone's opinions.

that one guy wrote: ↑Tue Jan 17, 2017 7:56 am I'm on the opposite side it seems...give me Aaron Rodgers and Ingram all day/every day at the price of KBenj and D Lewis

I don't see mention of what 1st round picks this new team might have, but getting Ingram to start the overhaul of the RB position and Rodgers at QB is a win IMO

Agreed...what am I missing that others see here? This is a clear win for the OP!

Haha, so the 2.12 and Higbee gets you CJA in addition to the original offer...good lord, I wish I'd get offers like that. Such a win for you

Great trade for you if you get anything even resembling what was mentioned above.

I will never understand the Ingram hate on these forums.
In PPG he finished...
8 in 2014
9 in 2015
11 in 2016

We search for consistency in RBs, a position at which maybe half of RB1 scorers post a 2nd year of RB1 nuumbers... and here we have Ingram with 3, back to back to back.

Ill take Ingram over KB, and Rodgers over any combo of the pieces combined.