Dynasty League Football Forum

We still have a couple of months before our keepers are due but I'd like to hear some opinions on who you would keep. We keep 4 players from our rosters, PPR, 6 points per passing TD...

My main players:

Matt Schaub

Adrian Peterson
Knowshon Moreno
Felix Jones
Cedric Benson

Andre Johnson
Marques Colston
Vincent Jackson

I have the 4th pick in the draft.

Thanks in advance for your opinions!

1. Peterson
2. Andre Johnson
3. M. Colston
4. K. Moreno

I have a feeling that you should still be able to get a quality Qb, so Schaub doesn't get protected here, and I think you keep Moreno due to the likelihood that a lot of RBs will end up protected here. Vincent Jackson is also a possibility to keep here if you wanted.

I forgot to add that we start the following:

QB: 1
RB: 2
WR: 2
TE: 1
RB/WR/TE: 2

What are the starting req's? I'll assume Q, R, R, W, W, flex, TE

1. Peterson (Obviously)
2. Andre Johnson (Just as Obviously)
3. Vincent Jackson (I like him over Colston by a small margin)
4. Moreno (just doubt you'll get much better a RB in the draft, though an argument could be made for Ryan Matthews)
4b. If you either start more WR's or less RB's, I'd make Colston my 4th keeper over Moreno. Also would be the case if somehow you expect any of Mendenhall, J Stew, or Chris Wells to be available)

Steelersfan wrote:We still have a couple of months before our keepers are due but I'd like to hear some opinions on who you would keep. We keep 4 players from our rosters, PPR, 6 points per passing TD...

My main players:

Matt Schaub

Adrian Peterson
Knowshon Moreno
Felix Jones
Cedric Benson

Andre Johnson
Marques Colston
Vincent Jackson

I have the 4th pick in the draft.

Thanks in advance for your opinions!

you'll get good numbers from Benson this year and hopefully acquire a better keeper next year.

Adrian Peterson Stability RB1
Knowshon Moreno Upside RB3

Andre Johnson Stability WR1
Marques Colston Stability WR2


you can either get a a younger more stable RB2 than Benson at 4, or you can just grab Benson at 4. Holding onto Moreno gives you that upside that you need to rebuild your team on the back-end....Colston has a higher ceiling than VJax so thats a no brainer....

Schaub, AP, AJ, Colston.

Schaub: I doubt there will be a better QB1 available with 6 points per TD, having a top QB can make or break your season.
AP: Automatic
AJ: automatic
Colston: Unless R.Mathews falls flat on his face - VJ's number are probably going down slightly with SD actually having a decent running game.

I think VJ, Benson, or Moreno gets back to you at the 4th pick.

MR ROURKE wrote:Schaub, AP, AJ, Colston.

Schaub: I doubt there will be a better QB1 available with 6 points per TD, having a top QB can make or break your season.
AP: Automatic
AJ: automatic
Colston: Unless R.Mathews falls flat on his face - VJ's number are probably going down slightly with SD actually having a decent running game.

I think VJ, Benson, or Moreno gets back to you at the 4th pick.

come on man...QB's are not worth keeping.........

1. Aaron Rodgers, GB - being kept
2. Drew Brees, NO - being kept
3. Peyton Manning, IND - maybe
4. Phillip Rivers, SD - being kept
5. Tom Brady, NE
6. Tony Romo, DAL - being kept
7. Matt Schaub, HOU
8. Matt Ryan, ATL
9. Eli Manning, NYG
10. Brett Favre, MIN
11. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT
12. Jay Cutler, CHI


4 QB's are almost GUARANTEED to be kept

the top 12 here do not even include guys like Kolb, Henne, Alex Smith or Flacco all potential top 12 options this year..so thats 11 quality QB's (if you minus Favre) among 8 teams.....nobody is spending a 2nd round pick on a backup QB....so Schaub should fall to the 2nd and if not then a QB just as good will fall to the 2nd if not even the 3rd, or 4th. QB's are less of a luxury no matter how many points per TD pass - unless you begin to include bonuses, and points per completion, the demand is still not as high because the supply is always high.

And as far as drafting is concerned its usually better to do the OPPOSITE of what everyone else is doing in order to strategically outmaneuver other managers....so 4 teams are going to let go of decent RB's and WR's to keep a QB.....make them pay for that by drafting one of those RB's or WR's in the 1st and 2nd and then a QB in the 3rd guys like Kolb, Henne, Flacco should still be there, guaranteed.

princevincexoxo wrote:1. Aaron Rodgers, GB - being kept
2. Drew Brees, NO - being kept
3. Peyton Manning, IND - maybe
4. Phillip Rivers, SD - being kept
5. Tom Brady, NE
6. Tony Romo, DAL - being kept
7. Matt Schaub, HOU
8. Matt Ryan, ATL
9. Eli Manning, NYG
10. Brett Favre, MIN
11. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT
12. Jay Cutler, CHI


4 QB's are almost GUARANTEED to be kept

the top 12 here do not even include guys like Kolb, Henne, Alex Smith or Flacco all potential top 12 options this year..so thats 11 quality QB's (if you minus Favre) among 8 teams.....nobody is spending a 2nd round pick on a backup QB....so Schaub should fall to the 2nd and if not then a QB just as good will fall to the 2nd if not even the 3rd, or 4th.

As far as drafting is concerned its usually better to do the OPPOSITE of what everyone else is doing in order to strategically outmaneuver other managers....

wait a second...are you saying you devalue quarterbacks in fantasy?



I agree with most of what you said, EXCEPT Vincent Jackson's ceiling is NO WAY lower than Colston. I love Colston as much as the next guy but he is a sell now candidate, imo. If anything, he has a high floor, low ceiling. Vjax was on pace for top 5 and then hit a slump later in the year. Meachum is emerging and will take some looks away from Colston.

Orca wrote:

princevincexoxo wrote:1. Aaron Rodgers, GB - being kept
2. Drew Brees, NO - being kept
3. Peyton Manning, IND - maybe
4. Phillip Rivers, SD - being kept
5. Tom Brady, NE
6. Tony Romo, DAL - being kept
7. Matt Schaub, HOU
8. Matt Ryan, ATL
9. Eli Manning, NYG
10. Brett Favre, MIN
11. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT
12. Jay Cutler, CHI


4 QB's are almost GUARANTEED to be kept

the top 12 here do not even include guys like Kolb, Henne, Alex Smith or Flacco all potential top 12 options this year..so thats 11 quality QB's (if you minus Favre) among 8 teams.....nobody is spending a 2nd round pick on a backup QB....so Schaub should fall to the 2nd and if not then a QB just as good will fall to the 2nd if not even the 3rd, or 4th.

As far as drafting is concerned its usually better to do the OPPOSITE of what everyone else is doing in order to strategically outmaneuver other managers....

wait a second...are you saying you devalue quarterbacks in fantasy?



I agree with most of what you said, EXCEPT Vincent Jackson's ceiling is NO WAY lower than Colston.

prove it...

I thought this did:

I love Colston as much as the next guy but he is a sell now candidate, imo. If anything, he has a high floor, low ceiling. Vjax was on pace for top 5 and then hit a slump later in the year. Meachum is emerging and will take some looks away from Colston.

going out shopping...I'll be back later to put something more compelling together

Orca wrote:I thought this did:

I love Colston as much as the next guy but he is a sell now candidate, imo. If anything, he has a high floor, low ceiling. Vjax was on pace for top 5 and then hit a slump later in the year. Meachum is emerging and will take some looks away from Colston.

going out shopping...I'll be back later to put something more compelling together

I'll save u the time

Colston Yearly Averages
14 games 71 catches 1020 yards 8 TD's (5 catches per game for his career)
Career High 98 catches in 16 games (6.1 catches per game)
Career Low 47 catches in 11 games (4.25 catches per game=68 catches in 16 games)

You can tell me all about Vincent Jacksons averages highs and lows

The fact is if anything Colstons floor has proven to be VJax's ceiling...

princevincexoxo wrote:

Orca wrote:I thought this did:

I love Colston as much as the next guy but he is a sell now candidate, imo. If anything, he has a high floor, low ceiling. Vjax was on pace for top 5 and then hit a slump later in the year. Meachum is emerging and will take some looks away from Colston.

going out shopping...I'll be back later to put something more compelling together

I'll save u the time

Colston Yearly Averages
14 games 71 catches 1020 yards 8 TD's
5 catches per game for 4 years
Career High 98 catches in 16 games (6.1 catches per game)
Career Low 47 catches in 11 games (4.25 catches per game=68 catches in 16 games)


You can tell me all about Vincent Jacksons averages highs and lows

this isn't a discussion of averages . Quite the opposite. It is a discussion of extremes...ceilings and floors. I have something in mind, but let me buy some fruits and vegetables first ok.

Orca wrote:

princevincexoxo wrote:

Orca wrote:I thought this did:

I love Colston as much as the next guy but he is a sell now candidate, imo. If anything, he has a high floor, low ceiling. Vjax was on pace for top 5 and then hit a slump later in the year. Meachum is emerging and will take some looks away from Colston.

going out shopping...I'll be back later to put something more compelling together

I'll save u the time

Colston Yearly Averages
14 games 71 catches 1020 yards 8 TD's
5 catches per game for 4 years
Career High 98 catches in 16 games (6.1 catches per game)
Career Low 47 catches in 11 games (4.25 catches per game=68 catches in 16 games)


You can tell me all about Vincent Jacksons averages highs and lows

this isn't a discussion of averages . Quite the opposite. It is a discussion of extremes...ceilings and floors. I have something in mind, but let me buy some fruits and vegetables first ok.

ok 98 catches
70 catches
70 catches
and a projected 68 catches

in comparison to
41 catches
59 catches
68 catches

ur fighting a losing battle my friend.....