trade offered

[gratefulydead3]

hey guys, I was just offered chester taylor and the 1.03 rookie pick for colston

What side would you rather have and if colston, what should I add to make it even? Thanks in advance for the opinions

[meineymoe]

I'm not one for handcuffing, but I could see Taylor unseat Forte in Chicago... still it comes down to your starting requirements - you aren't that deep at quality WRs.... Spiller or Dez Bryant at 1.03 makes this trade more intriguing.

-oo-

[Scorp]

Earlier this year, I traded Colston for Sanchez and a 2011 first round pick. I felt with all the receiving options in New Orleans, that Colston wasn't a top 8 PPR receiver anymore. Meachem and Lance Moore are becoming more relevant in that offense, although Colston is still a nice red zone threat. C.Taylor and 1.3 isn't enough for Colston imo, but to even it out, I'd want either a QB and the 1.3 like I did, or 1.3 + a RB like Lynch.

[Pilate]

hey guys, I was just offered chester taylor and the 1.03 rookie pick for colston

What side would you rather have and if colston, what should I add to make it even? Thanks in advance for the opinions

I believe in proven talent anytime over a rookie player/pick. Colston is a low end WR1 who plays in a pass first offense. Finished last season with 70 receptions and 9 TD's in an offense that has several other excellent weapons.

I would take that trade without hesitation.

[gratefulydead3]

Earlier this year, I traded Colston for Sanchez and a 2011 first round pick. I felt with all the receiving options in New Orleans, that Colston wasn't a top 8 PPR receiver anymore. Meachem and Lance Moore are becoming more relevant in that offense, although Colston is still a nice red zone threat. C.Taylor and 1.3 isn't enough for Colston imo, but to even it out, I'd want either a QB and the 1.3 like I did, or 1.3 + a RB like Lynch.

The guy has manning, rogers, and stafford, but I think h plans on keep both rogers and manning and I'm not a huge stafford fan. I want the 1.3 and taylor so what if I made it 1.3/taylor/2.3 for colston/jerome simpson. The other owner has mendenhall, moreno, ronnie brown, and lynch so WR is his main need

[Scorp]

Earlier this year, I traded Colston for Sanchez and a 2011 first round pick. I felt with all the receiving options in New Orleans, that Colston wasn't a top 8 PPR receiver anymore. Meachem and Lance Moore are becoming more relevant in that offense, although Colston is still a nice red zone threat. C.Taylor and 1.3 isn't enough for Colston imo, but to even it out, I'd want either a QB and the 1.3 like I did, or 1.3 + a RB like Lynch.

The guy has manning, rogers, and stafford, but I think h plans on keep both rogers and manning and I'm not a huge stafford fan. I want the 1.3 and taylor so what if I made it 1.3/taylor/2.3 for colston/jerome simpson. The other owner has mendenhall, moreno, ronnie brown, and lynch so WR is his main need

It's obvious he's targetting Bryant, I still would want Lynch + 1.3 for Colston.

Edit: Nevermind, looks like he wants to keep Lynch, and wants Spiller.

[Scorp]

1.3/taylor/2.3 for colston/jerome simpson is value for you, but it isn't the way I'd go about it to get Bryant because you might end up with Taylor/Spiller/Gilyard or something like that.

[gratefulydead3]

No Dez will be there. The 1.1 moved up after the Chargers got Mathews (he's a sproles owner) and the 1.2 only has 1 startable option at RB with McCoy so he'll be forced to take Spiller. 1.3 I get Dez and then at 1.6 I'll take Best/Tate if they are still on the board (I'm confident Tate will be there).

Ideally it would end up as Dez/Chester Taylor/BPA at 2.3 Gresham maybe for Colston/Jerome Simpson

[Steelersfan]

No Dez will be there. The 1.1 moved up after the Chargers got Mathews (he's a sproles owner) and the 1.2 only has 1 startable option at RB with McCoy so he'll be forced to take Spiller. 1.3 I get Dez and then at 1.6 I'll take Best/Tate if they are still on the board (I'm confident Tate will be there).

Ideally it would end up as Dez/Chester Taylor/BPA at 2.3 Gresham maybe for Colston/Jerome Simpson

I think I would gamble a bit and take the deal.

[MrUbuto]

the guy offering the trade is kinda dumb, he could keep chester and just take dez himself. dez is an instant top tier WR2 from week 1

[pvballer3915]

u get a deal if u take it. Colston is great but dez as a boy could be bettr!

[skip]

Colston by a WIDE margin. Rookie picks are far too much of a gamble. Chester's value is extremely limited. This is Colston for the 1.3 and I take Colston there all day long.

[pvballer3915]

Colston by a WIDE margin. Rookie picks are far too much of a gamble. Chester's value is extremely limited. This is Colston for the 1.3 and I take Colston there all day long.

why do u say chester has no value. they didnt sign him to that contract for no reason..

[skip]

Colston by a WIDE margin. Rookie picks are far too much of a gamble. Chester's value is extremely limited. This is Colston for the 1.3 and I take Colston there all day long.

why do u say chester has no value. they didnt sign him to that contract for no reason..

If you want to invest in a RB who will hit 31 the first month of the season, feel free. A player at that position and of that age has limited value.

[pvballer3915]

Colston by a WIDE margin. Rookie picks are far too much of a gamble. Chester's value is extremely limited. This is Colston for the 1.3 and I take Colston there all day long.

why do u say chester has no value. they didnt sign him to that contract for no reason..

If you want to invest in a RB who will hit 31 the first month of the season, feel free. A player at that position and of that age has limited value.

alright heres where i see the difference. They say the age a RB dies out is at 30 right? The difference between chester and most rbs is that he was really never a workhorse as an nfl rb. He was always that role guy. There was only one season in which he had over 200 rushing attempts and that was his first year as a vike with 303. My point is his legs are still sumwhat fresh and havent been driven into the grund. Thats why i think Taylor will have a solid year. This mite also bring Forte out of his lil loop he has goin on..

Just what i think