1.01 or White+

[operwapitsai]

Team 2

Won it all last year with no-names at RB.
the owner of the 1.01 is in full rebuild and is also the owner of J. Charles.

So the deal would play out as Zeke for White + late 1st OR Charcandrick West


What side and possibly why. Additional pieces that could even it out?

[dshaw021]

This is fairly close for me, but I think I'd rather have the 1.01 and take Zeke. White has the upside to be great, but he also comes with much more risk. The 1.12 is a nice bridge piece, but in this draft it doesn't hold as much value.

[n20]

With your WR core, I think you can take the loss of White's potential and really strength to your much needed RB core with Zeke.

If you agree with this year's draft being weaker, you could offer essentially:
a. White, C West, for 1.01 (Zeke)
b. 1.12 for 2017 second rounder (likely high if rebuilding, 2.01? he'd gain more perceived value to rebuild in 2016)

[ImaRounder]

White is on the end of your bench, make the trade

[Parker8]

Agree. Your good at wr and that's much lower than I've seen the 1.01 go got... MUCH LOWER

[DonBrazi]

I think it's a horrible idea to move White for less than value simply because you have a lot of depth. Maybe come September and doing so dramatically boosts your expected weekly points. But it's March... way too early to trade for expected need.

White is easily as talented as any player in this year's draft, so adding a 1st to him seems like a hefty overpay to me.

[HEADBANGER]

To get Zeke (a RB you really need) giving up White and 1.12 seems about right. I say go for it and good luck.

[HEADBANGER]

I think it's a horrible idea to move White for less than value simply because you have a lot of depth. Maybe come September and doing so dramatically boosts your expected weekly points. But it's March... way too early to trade for expected need.

White is easily as talented as any player in this year's draft, so adding a 1st to him seems like a hefty overpay to me.

How is this a hefty overpay? This would be 1.1 (Zeke for need and to me is BPA) for White (1.3 or 1.4 last year) and 1.12 which is a total crap shoot. Value wise this is pretty legit OR C West to the Charles owner since is a bench player for the OP. White only jumped up the board last year due to the combine and landing spot, not for his proven college production which was basically one solid year.

[HawkeyeState]

White and 1.12 for me.
I have White in the 1.02 conversation if he was in this years class and I feel I can fairly confidently predict a nice breakout for him this year.

Now if it was White and Charcandrick, I think I would want Zeke.
Zeke I have slightly ahead of White and IMO West is just a wasted roster spot at this point.
See if you can get a early 3rd thrown on to the 1.01 side and slam accept that if you can get it.

I voted in the poll for the White 1.12 side assuming that was the deal but if you can do it with West instead of 1.12 I would side the other with 1.01

[DonBrazi]

How is this a hefty overpay? This would be 1.1 (Zeke for need and to me is BPA) for White (1.3 or 1.4 last year) and 1.12 which is a total crap shoot. Value wise this is pretty legit OR C West to the Charles owner since is a bench player for the OP. White only jumped up the board last year due to the combine and landing spot, not for his proven college production which was basically one solid year.

In my opinion, were White in this year's class, he would very much be in the conversation for the 1.01, if not the clear 1.01. Even if he was the 1.02 behind Elliot (whom I'm not sure is the 1.01, even), it'd be an overpay to me.

I don't think the combine pushed White up the board last year. He was the consensus 1.03 before the combine and was in the conversation for the 1.01 after it, but still went as the 1.03 in the end.. Further, Zeke only has one solid year under his belt as well (ok, ok.. plus 3 games to end 2014). Not sure that's a good argument against White in this case.

[dblj1199]

This is fairly close for me, but I think I'd rather have the 1.01 and take Zeke. White has the upside to be great, but he also comes with much more risk. The 1.12 is a nice bridge piece, but in this draft it doesn't hold as much value.

Couldn't have said it better myself.

[operwapitsai]

Thanks for the input guys!

[operwapitsai]

This is fairly close for me, but I think I'd rather have the 1.01 and take Zeke. White has the upside to be great, but he also comes with much more risk. The 1.12 is a nice bridge piece, but in this draft it doesn't hold as much value.

What makes you think White is more risky than Zeke?
White is a top 10 pick at WR, a much more reliable position, and top 10 picks at WR tend to pan out relatively well.

Zeke hasn't even been drafted yet?...

I can agree with the 1.12 reasoning though.

[operwapitsai]

White and 1.12 for me.
I have White in the 1.02 conversation if he was in this years class and I feel I can fairly confidently predict a nice breakout for him this year.

Now if it was White and Charcandrick, I think I would want Zeke.
Zeke I have slightly ahead of White and IMO West is just a wasted roster spot at this point.
See if you can get a early 3rd thrown on to the 1.01 side and slam accept that if you can get it.

I voted in the poll for the White 1.12 side assuming that was the deal but if you can do it with West instead of 1.12 I would side the other with 1.01

I think it's a horrible idea to move White for less than value simply because you have a lot of depth. Maybe come September and doing so dramatically boosts your expected weekly points. But it's March... way too early to trade for expected need.

White is easily as talented as any player in this year's draft, so adding a 1st to him seems like a hefty overpay to me.

I value both of your opinions pretty highly around here. Its interesting you are the 2 most in favor of the White side.

I figured I was losing a bit of value in this trade, but there is not much use in having 6/7 startable WRs with only 3 possible starting spots. Especially when I can't really rely on any one of my available RBs.


viewtopic.php?f=6&t=116361
(other owner)


Rookie fever seems to be in full swing.

[Draft Master]

if White was coming out of this years draft, maybe he would be the 1.01 ?