Nacua vs Mayers

[slaughterrt]

If it's a 2TEP, Mayer was likely a mid to late 1st. Getting a young TE with upside potential isn't easy in that format. You will feel dumb as heck if Puka turns back into a pumpkin and you didn't sell him when you had the chance.

yes , there is that side too. He revoked so i sent it back to him now on him.

That's me! We're in the same league

[CGW]

had to come back and check on this one how we feeling now?

Do we make dynasty decisions based on every single week now? Or did I miss it and this was a redraft inquiry?

Sure, Puka is far and away more useful today...but if Mayer is even remotely startable in a 2TEP format, it'll even out.

[BigBawseRoss]

had to come back and check on this one how we feeling now?

Do we make dynasty decisions based on every single week now? Or did I miss it and this was a redraft inquiry?

Sure, Puka is far and away more useful today...but if Mayer is even remotely startable in a 2TEP format, it'll even out.

no but the community loves to write off surprises and say sell high or get off now before the let down and this was one of those cases. and i dont agree it would even out by mayer being a usable te... nacua is getting absurd volume and is absolutely the real deal.

[mikedigs]

yes , there is that side too. He revoked so i sent it back to him now on him.

That's me! We're in the same league

Interesting had no idea, it sure explains some thing lol.

This is an awesome forum moment! I always wonder if my league mates are here and if they see my posts.

[CGW]

had to come back and check on this one how we feeling now?

Do we make dynasty decisions based on every single week now? Or did I miss it and this was a redraft inquiry?

Sure, Puka is far and away more useful today...but if Mayer is even remotely startable in a 2TEP format, it'll even out.

no but the community loves to write off surprises and say sell high or get off now before the let down and this was one of those cases. and i dont agree it would even out by mayer being a usable te... nacua is getting absurd volume and is absolutely the real deal.

Sure, and I remember when folks were banging the hammer and saying Travis Fulgham was the next star after his hot start in 2020. I was too "stuck in my old evaluations" when I suggested selling. Puka could be the real deal. He did a lot to show it wasn't a fluke yesterday. But there's still nothing wrong with selling high. There's a lot of value in that, even if it's early.

Point is, there no value in weekly victory laps. Dynasty valuations should be long term and objective. There's zero way to know with certainty how either of these players turn out so we are all just guessing based on their traits and situations.

[BigBawseRoss]

Do we make dynasty decisions based on every single week now? Or did I miss it and this was a redraft inquiry?

Sure, Puka is far and away more useful today...but if Mayer is even remotely startable in a 2TEP format, it'll even out.

no but the community loves to write off surprises and say sell high or get off now before the let down and this was one of those cases. and i dont agree it would even out by mayer being a usable te... nacua is getting absurd volume and is absolutely the real deal.

Sure, and I remember when folks were banging the hammer and saying Travis Fulgham was the next star after his hot start in 2020. I was too "stuck in my old evaluations" when I suggested selling. Puka could be the real deal. He did a lot to show it wasn't a fluke yesterday. But there's still nothing wrong with selling high. There's a lot of value in that, even if it's early.

Point is, there no value in weekly victory laps. Dynasty valuations should be long term and objective. There's zero way to know with certainty how either of these players turn out so we are all just guessing based on their traits and situations.

I just had conviction on this one as i liked pukas tape and profile a lot. had to victory lap it after you used my own words to mock me haha. its all good tho no hard feelings. i learned my lesson of dont sell high when everyone says to off tyreek hill so i generally take a wait and see approach, cashing out on the pachecos of the world for a 3rd because you got em for free sometimes works but when it backfires you feel that for years and think about it like man why did i hurry and sell.

[frerichs5]

no but the community loves to write off surprises and say sell high or get off now before the let down and this was one of those cases. and i dont agree it would even out by mayer being a usable te... nacua is getting absurd volume and is absolutely the real deal.

Sure, and I remember when folks were banging the hammer and saying Travis Fulgham was the next star after his hot start in 2020. I was too "stuck in my old evaluations" when I suggested selling. Puka could be the real deal. He did a lot to show it wasn't a fluke yesterday. But there's still nothing wrong with selling high. There's a lot of value in that, even if it's early.

Point is, there no value in weekly victory laps. Dynasty valuations should be long term and objective. There's zero way to know with certainty how either of these players turn out so we are all just guessing based on their traits and situations.

I just had conviction on this one as i liked pukas tape and profile a lot. had to victory lap it after you used my own words to mock me haha. its all good tho no hard feelings. i learned my lesson of dont sell high when everyone says to off tyreek hill so i generally take a wait and see approach, cashing out on the pachecos of the world for a 3rd because you got em for free sometimes works but when it backfires you feel that for years and think about it like man why did i hurry and sell.

I agree with most of this. I think it comes down to dynasty mindset. I feel like I’ve been burned more holding onto guys too long, so I tend to move for value early nowadays. And it has definitely bit me a few times. Other times it works out great. I don’t think either side is wrong here yet. It will take time to play out.

[lukkynumber13]

Man… in a 2PPR league I’m not sad to be holding Mayer but holy crap Nacua might be for real for real

[tsarpepe]

had to come back and check on this one how we feeling now?

Do we make dynasty decisions based on every single week now? Or did I miss it and this was a redraft inquiry?

Sure, Puka is far and away more useful today...but if Mayer is even remotely startable in a 2TEP format, it'll even out.

I don't see anything paradoxical in making decisions in dynasty on the basis of 1-2 games. Dynasty is all about potential; and potential sometimes is revealed in 1-2 games. Puka did not just pop off. He is setting records, and no matter how many targets Kupp commands when he comes back, this guy is here to stay. These two games have shown 1) elite ability to get open (reported throughout camp); and 2) amazing synergy with Stafford. You bet I'm making my dynasty decision on the basis of this!