Let’s settle it: CEH or JT

[WOATjohn]

I own two 1.01 (1QB) and I’ll probably get one share of each of them.

[Cult of Dionysus]

The poll results would be very different had you asked which guy will score a lot more fantasy points over the next 3 years.

[Cowboysfan33]

I own 1.02 in a couple of leagues and I’ll be just fine, taking whomever is left between those two players. If I had to pick one, I still go J.Taylor but it’s pretty much flip a coin. I don’t play redraft any more, mainly due to being in so many dynasty leagues, but if I did I would take CEH over Taylor in that format. I don’t think you can wrong with either RB in dynasty though, it’s just so close, IMO.

[OhCruelestRanter]

Well, bleep.

842D06DC-523C-4811-992E-8F82DAD13C01.jpeg (77.11 KiB) Viewed 879 times

[nathanq42]

Lol, I got it to 35-35

He is my thought process

these cats are great football players in great situations, JT with a steamroller of an Oline, ready spring that 226 lbs. train with 4.39 on a rough night speed. He has the production, he has the measurables, he has the draft capital, he has a solid coach. CEH with the goat of all goats at QB, an amazing coach, the draft capital, amazing burst scores, not the best 40 or height, but guys have managed, plus his 10 yard splits isn't terrible. Have loved Dobbins through the whole process, he is number 2 or 3 in every category it seems, solid capital, good team that is going to tote the rock and break other teams' wills. Coin flip, I was higher on JT before and I'm leaning him currently, but honestly who knows, my opinion with change with the wind.

[LPN]

in standard JT and its not even close, in PPR CEH and its not even close

[FantasyFreak]

in standard JT and its not even close, in PPR CEH and its not even close

Disagree with that. I think it's very close no matter what side you are on.

[Jigga94]

in standard JT and its not even close, in PPR CEH and its not even close

Disagree with that. I think it's very close no matter what side you are on.

Crazy to think 1 ppr makes it "not even close" for either side. Even if CEH caught 100 passes and JT caught 0, that would mean the most they could be apart is 50 points either side. Hmm...

[Sriracha]

In the next 4 years, these guys are neck and neck regardless of format. JT caught 26 (!) balls his senior year.. he's not AJ Dillon.

But in their next contract... who is more situation proof? JT or CEH?

My money's on JT; but we'll find out soon enough.

[FantasyFreak]

In the next 4 years, these guys are neck and neck regardless of format. JT caught 26 (!) balls his senior year.. he's not AJ Dillon.

But in their next contract... who is more situation proof? JT or CEH?

My money's on JT; but we'll find out soon enough.

Junior year, but I get your point.

[Kurt G.O.A.T.]

if it came to the crunch i would go JT.

luckily i don't own the 1.01 anywhere so i won't have to make that decision.

[Jfever]

I got the 1.02 & 1.04. I’m thinking I’ll get two of JT, CEH, Dobbins, or Swift. Two great additions either way it falls. I personally prefer JT by a bit but I agree , it’s splitting hairs.

In the DLF HOF league, I have the 1.04 & 1.12

[bjd5211]

in standard JT and its not even close, in PPR CEH and its not even close

Disagree with that. I think it's very close no matter what side you are on.

Leonard Fournette had just as many questions about his receiving ability coming out of college, and similar receiving production as Taylor, and he had 76 receptions last year which is a great number for any RB.

[DynastyDabbler]

I haven't seen anyone talking about Taylor's fumbling issue. 18 fumbles throughout his college career, losing 15 of them. We all know that's the quickest way to lose touches in the NFL. Is this not a concern? I've also heard people knocking CEH for his lack of pass pro. Which of the issues is the bigger problem?

I grabbed CEH with the 1.01.

[Johnny B. Goode]

I haven't seen anyone talking about Taylor's fumbling issue. 18 fumbles throughout his college career, losing 15 of them. We all know that's the quickest way to lose touches in the NFL. Is this not a concern? I've also heard people knocking CEH for his lack of pass pro. Which of the issues is the bigger problem?

I grabbed CEH with the 1.01.

It's been talked about a lot in the JT 1.01 thread. I even was one bringing it up often.

It's somewhat of a concern but as others have pointed out it's something that almost never carries over from college to the NFL

Bad pass pro is a difference of not wanting to hit vs being unable. I am not sure where CEH lands there but IMO if you have the league MVP you want him protected

I feel CEH is destined for a rbbc situation relying on receptions to increase his value. I dont see him as the gl back, which limits his scoring potential. Taylor can do everything and doesn't need to come off the field ever. More playing time means more opportunity for points. I'm really hoping Taylor falls to me at 1.02