Who do you think would translate into a better NFL QB option.
Christian Hackenberg or Bryce Petty?
Obviously watching them this season would go a long way to determining this answer. Unfortunatly I don't have the option of waiting and watching.
Winston, Mariota and Hundly are also irrelevant as they are long gone out of this equation.
Any thoughts at all would be greatly appreciated.
I need a future QB opinion
-
- Player of the Year
- Posts: 2117
- Joined: Fri Feb 22, 2013 11:46 am
Re: I need a future QB opinion
Hackenberg for me. You'll have to wait a bit longer, but Petty is old, and I like Hackenberg's talent level more anyway. Sucks you can't wait and watch this year, but Hackenberg for me if you're picking now.
-
- Starter
- Posts: 701
- Joined: Wed Apr 11, 2012 3:19 pm
Re: I need a future QB opinion
With Winston, Mariota, and Hundley already taken in our devy draft last year, Hackenberg went almost two full rounds before Petty in our recently completed 2014 devy draft (2.1 vs. 3.11 respectively).
16-tm, 1-PPR, (SK:TK 3:1.5)
1QB 2RB 3WR 1TE 1K 3DL 4LB 4DB
QB: Brady, Dalton
RB: Murray, DMart, Bernard, R Mathews, K Dixon
WR: Bryant, OBJ, Evans, Ty Hill, M Jones, Ty Williams, Gabriel, Beasley, Inman, Peake
TE: Eifert, J Thomas, Tye
K: Walsh
DL: Ansah, Wake, C Johnson, M Johnson, Fowler, Ygakoue
LB: D Jones, J Hicks, D Harris, Compton, M Kendricks
DB: Church, Graham, Quin, McDougald
12-tm Devy, .5PPR, (SK:TK 5:1)
1QB 2-3RB 3-5WR 1-2TE 3DL 3LB 3DB
QB: Cam, Stafford, E Manning, Cousins
RB: Bell, McCoy, Martin, Lacy, JStew, J White, J Rodgers
WR: Brown, OBJ, D Bryant, M Thomas, Decker, M Jones, Gabriel, Garcon, T Smith
TE: Reed, Henry, Rudolph
DL: Mack, Donald, Cox, Richardson, M Jackson, Spence
LB: Shazier, T Davis, Barron, Ingram, Barron, Kerrigan
DB: K Coleman, Nelson, Addae
1QB 2RB 3WR 1TE 1K 3DL 4LB 4DB
QB: Brady, Dalton
RB: Murray, DMart, Bernard, R Mathews, K Dixon
WR: Bryant, OBJ, Evans, Ty Hill, M Jones, Ty Williams, Gabriel, Beasley, Inman, Peake
TE: Eifert, J Thomas, Tye
K: Walsh
DL: Ansah, Wake, C Johnson, M Johnson, Fowler, Ygakoue
LB: D Jones, J Hicks, D Harris, Compton, M Kendricks
DB: Church, Graham, Quin, McDougald
12-tm Devy, .5PPR, (SK:TK 5:1)
1QB 2-3RB 3-5WR 1-2TE 3DL 3LB 3DB
QB: Cam, Stafford, E Manning, Cousins
RB: Bell, McCoy, Martin, Lacy, JStew, J White, J Rodgers
WR: Brown, OBJ, D Bryant, M Thomas, Decker, M Jones, Gabriel, Garcon, T Smith
TE: Reed, Henry, Rudolph
DL: Mack, Donald, Cox, Richardson, M Jackson, Spence
LB: Shazier, T Davis, Barron, Ingram, Barron, Kerrigan
DB: K Coleman, Nelson, Addae
- rubber_duck
- Pro Bowler
- Posts: 1126
- Joined: Thu Dec 27, 2012 11:02 am
Re: I need a future QB opinion
Winston was taken in your 2013 devy draft? That is one astute move, most people had never heard of him and he hadn't seen the field at the college level. What other players has that owner snapped up? I would like to add them to my watch list.NewtotheBiz wrote:With Winston, Mariota, and Hundley already taken in our devy draft last year, Hackenberg went almost two full rounds before Petty in our recently completed 2014 devy draft (2.1 vs. 3.11 respectively).
-
- Starter
- Posts: 701
- Joined: Wed Apr 11, 2012 3:19 pm
Re: I need a future QB opinion
Well, your hardcore college football fans and devy players had heard of him, and at the point of our draft he was taken, you are banking almost solely on potential. Winston just paid off for this particular owner. I took Thomas Tyner in the same draft before he had ever taken a snap and now he is a consensus top-5 pick. You just watch high school film and hope what your eye sees translates to the college level.
Each year as the talent pool is thinned out, more and more college freshmen are taken before they ever see the field. Volatility is high, but the payout can be huge in relation to their initial price. Similar to stock market IPOs.
Each year as the talent pool is thinned out, more and more college freshmen are taken before they ever see the field. Volatility is high, but the payout can be huge in relation to their initial price. Similar to stock market IPOs.
16-tm, 1-PPR, (SK:TK 3:1.5)
1QB 2RB 3WR 1TE 1K 3DL 4LB 4DB
QB: Brady, Dalton
RB: Murray, DMart, Bernard, R Mathews, K Dixon
WR: Bryant, OBJ, Evans, Ty Hill, M Jones, Ty Williams, Gabriel, Beasley, Inman, Peake
TE: Eifert, J Thomas, Tye
K: Walsh
DL: Ansah, Wake, C Johnson, M Johnson, Fowler, Ygakoue
LB: D Jones, J Hicks, D Harris, Compton, M Kendricks
DB: Church, Graham, Quin, McDougald
12-tm Devy, .5PPR, (SK:TK 5:1)
1QB 2-3RB 3-5WR 1-2TE 3DL 3LB 3DB
QB: Cam, Stafford, E Manning, Cousins
RB: Bell, McCoy, Martin, Lacy, JStew, J White, J Rodgers
WR: Brown, OBJ, D Bryant, M Thomas, Decker, M Jones, Gabriel, Garcon, T Smith
TE: Reed, Henry, Rudolph
DL: Mack, Donald, Cox, Richardson, M Jackson, Spence
LB: Shazier, T Davis, Barron, Ingram, Barron, Kerrigan
DB: K Coleman, Nelson, Addae
1QB 2RB 3WR 1TE 1K 3DL 4LB 4DB
QB: Brady, Dalton
RB: Murray, DMart, Bernard, R Mathews, K Dixon
WR: Bryant, OBJ, Evans, Ty Hill, M Jones, Ty Williams, Gabriel, Beasley, Inman, Peake
TE: Eifert, J Thomas, Tye
K: Walsh
DL: Ansah, Wake, C Johnson, M Johnson, Fowler, Ygakoue
LB: D Jones, J Hicks, D Harris, Compton, M Kendricks
DB: Church, Graham, Quin, McDougald
12-tm Devy, .5PPR, (SK:TK 5:1)
1QB 2-3RB 3-5WR 1-2TE 3DL 3LB 3DB
QB: Cam, Stafford, E Manning, Cousins
RB: Bell, McCoy, Martin, Lacy, JStew, J White, J Rodgers
WR: Brown, OBJ, D Bryant, M Thomas, Decker, M Jones, Gabriel, Garcon, T Smith
TE: Reed, Henry, Rudolph
DL: Mack, Donald, Cox, Richardson, M Jackson, Spence
LB: Shazier, T Davis, Barron, Ingram, Barron, Kerrigan
DB: K Coleman, Nelson, Addae
Re: I need a future QB opinion
rubber_duck wrote:Winston was taken in your 2013 devy draft? That is one astute move, most people had never heard of him and he hadn't seen the field at the college level. What other players has that owner snapped up? I would like to add them to my watch list.NewtotheBiz wrote:With Winston, Mariota, and Hundley already taken in our devy draft last year, Hackenberg went almost two full rounds before Petty in our recently completed 2014 devy draft (2.1 vs. 3.11 respectively).
That's kind of in the same situation with these qb's that I'm in. That's why I posted the original question.
This league is a 20 teamer. It was 18 for years, and all good owners. I was an expansion team, yadda, yadda, yadda.
But it's a salary cap,contract, idp, auction league. With a 2 player devy draft every year. Now you can imagine how much a good QB, even a starting one is worth in a league like this with 20 teams. Heck, Mike Glennon was a stud last year, just because he could start.
So when the devy's come around. You really try to nail a qb, even if you sit on him.
Re: I need a future QB opinion
That's a great call with the age. I hadn't even thought of that yet.italian_stallion21 wrote:Hackenberg for me. You'll have to wait a bit longer, but Petty is old, and I like Hackenberg's talent level more anyway. Sucks you can't wait and watch this year, but Hackenberg for me if you're picking now.
Yes I think Hackenberg it is for me.
Re: I need a future QB opinion
Hackenberg. Petty has accuracy issues.
-
- All Pro
- Posts: 1836
- Joined: Thu Apr 25, 2013 3:19 pm
Re: I need a future QB opinion
He's older I grant you but he's a 23 year old senior. That's not old for a QB. It's not like we're talking Brandon Weeden here.italian_stallion21 wrote:Hackenberg for me. You'll have to wait a bit longer, but Petty is old, and I like Hackenberg's talent level more anyway. Sucks you can't wait and watch this year, but Hackenberg for me if you're picking now.
16 Team PPR (11th Year Dynasty - Former 2 Time Champion)
P. Mahomes, Z. Wilson
C. McCaffrey, N. Harris, C. Hubbard
D. Hopkins, A. Cooper, C. Kupp, D. Johnson, G. Davis, D. Mims, J. Palmer
D. Waller, C. Kmet, B. Jordan
C. Young, R. Quinn
D. Leonard, M. Milano, C. Mosely, B. Okereke, J. Davis
J. Simmons, J. Fuller
Picks - 1.01, 2.12, 3.01, 3.15, 4.14
16 Team PPR (10th Year Dynasty - Reigning 5 Time Champion)
A. Rodgers, J. Fields
C. McCaffrey, D. Henry, J. Dobbins, M. Davis
D. Hopkins, D. Adams, C. Kupp, M. Jones, M. Valdes-Scantling, A. Green, T. Johnson, Dy. Brown, G. Pickens, J. Tolbert,
N. Fant, A. Okwugbunam, J. Harris
J. Elliott
D. Lawrence, R. Quinn, T. Hendrickson
R. Smith, B. Okereke, L. Wilson, J. Davis, D. Tranquil, B. Asamoah
J. Simmons, W. Harris
P. Mahomes, Z. Wilson
C. McCaffrey, N. Harris, C. Hubbard
D. Hopkins, A. Cooper, C. Kupp, D. Johnson, G. Davis, D. Mims, J. Palmer
D. Waller, C. Kmet, B. Jordan
C. Young, R. Quinn
D. Leonard, M. Milano, C. Mosely, B. Okereke, J. Davis
J. Simmons, J. Fuller
Picks - 1.01, 2.12, 3.01, 3.15, 4.14
16 Team PPR (10th Year Dynasty - Reigning 5 Time Champion)
A. Rodgers, J. Fields
C. McCaffrey, D. Henry, J. Dobbins, M. Davis
D. Hopkins, D. Adams, C. Kupp, M. Jones, M. Valdes-Scantling, A. Green, T. Johnson, Dy. Brown, G. Pickens, J. Tolbert,
N. Fant, A. Okwugbunam, J. Harris
J. Elliott
D. Lawrence, R. Quinn, T. Hendrickson
R. Smith, B. Okereke, L. Wilson, J. Davis, D. Tranquil, B. Asamoah
J. Simmons, W. Harris
-
- Player of the Year
- Posts: 2117
- Joined: Fri Feb 22, 2013 11:46 am
Re: I need a future QB opinion
No, but historically speaking the younger QB's out of college tend to be better.failblazer wrote:He's older I grant you but he's a 23 year old senior. That's not old for a QB. It's not like we're talking Brandon Weeden here.italian_stallion21 wrote:Hackenberg for me. You'll have to wait a bit longer, but Petty is old, and I like Hackenberg's talent level more anyway. Sucks you can't wait and watch this year, but Hackenberg for me if you're picking now.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 18 guests