Alshon Offer Pending

[Jimmy Jones]

Just sent an offer of Crabtree, Sanders, Pitta for Alshon. Anyone think I'm giving to much and should revoke it? Alshon having a bad start and Cutler locking on to Marshall makes me nervous. Crabtree looks like he might have a really big year..

[tidewaterjc]

TBH, doubt that gets it done....

pull out Pitta and throw in a 1.r and possible get him to negotiate.

[captain howdy]

It just seems like a "thems the breaks" type of start for Alshon.

Consider how many times in just a few games Alshon has been held/interfered with, negating a deep toss? I remember 4 separate plays..I dont believe it is an issue where Cutler isn't tossing to Alshon

Alshon was 6th IN THE LEAGUE last season and that was no fluke, and I dont buy that McCown made it happen and Cutler didnt or won't. With Alshon having a tweaked hammy it would not make sense to force it to him non stop, unless you have to, and with Marshall the Bears dont have to.

12 targets through 2 games where Alshon didnt play for one entire half and was hobbled for 2 other halfs is pretty decent usage.

I do not kno if your offer gets it done, but you would be getting a solid bargain on Alshon right there

[Jimmy Jones]

Thanks for talking some sense into me. What would be a fair offer then?

[henry1jg]

As an Alshon owner, I would not deal him for this offer.

[captain howdy]

Thanks for talking some sense into me. What would be a fair offer then?

Some people salivate over patterson. Even offering patterson instead kf crabtree may be enough. .depends on the on the owner...but patterson is much more sexy than crabs.

In a ten teamer with studs being so important, even crabs patterson and pitta ( given that you have graham and kelce and asj ) would not be too hard to swallow, with sanders and watkins ready to step up

[voiceofunreason]

Not close enough to counter imo. I need an elite player or a young guy who I think could become elite.

[ninotoreS]

You're throwing middle-tier quantity at the wall to try and secure a blue-chip dynasty stud.

[Typhus]

Not close enough to counter imo. I need an elite player or a young guy who I think could become elite.

Than your talking Cooks or Benjamin, thats about what your going to have to bring to the table for Alshon.

[NanceUSMC]

Feels like an overreaction trade TBH... I'd hold onto Alshon... Even with Marshall, AJ has the chance to be a top 10-15 WR in that offense... I don't believe anything you'd be getting in return has that kind of upside...

[Plank]

Yes, I'm looking forward to owning Alshon over his career... he really makes it look so easy...

[Jimmy Jones]

Yea, the offer was ingored. No counter, no decline. I might give it one more shot. I would love to have Julio and Alshon as 2 of my starting 3. Any good ideas on a better offer?

[voiceofunreason]

Yea, the offer was ingored. No counter, no decline. I might give it one more shot. I would love to have Julio and Alshon as 2 of my starting 3. Any good ideas on a better offer?

Watkins plus a piece, perhaps Kelce or maybe a guy like Sanders.

[Jimmy Jones]

Yea, the offer was ingored. No counter, no decline. I might give it one more shot. I would love to have Julio and Alshon as 2 of my starting 3. Any good ideas on a better offer?

Watkins plus a piece, perhaps Kelce.

I don't think he's interested in Watkins, he's looking to contend while he still can. I was hoping to find a way to do it while keeping Julio, Jimmy, and Watkins. I thought about Paterson, Crabtree, Kelce, but I think it's just too much.

[WashingtonFever]

I don't think so. Ask for a 2nd in return. See if he bites. Thought you said that Julio plus alshon would be sweet.