Julio trade

[cowboysfan]

Which side do you prefer?

Julio
or
Mike Evans, Julius Thomas, 2015 1st

I'm the Julio owner and I already have Patterson, Watkins, and Desean Jackson. Thanks for the advice.

[Mike11]

You already have a lottery ticket in Watkins and Patterson to some degree. Why trade a for sure thing for more maybes? Just my two cents, but You don't know what Julius Thomas's value is once Peyton leaves town. I'd rather keep Julio personally.

[vbbish]

I'm not that high on Thomas, especially without Manning. Would take more then that to get Julio from me...

[thebeast]

I'd keep Julio - I'm not sold on Evans and who knows who that 2015 1st will be. JT is just a TE - the difference between him and Charles Clay last year was just 30 pts - the difference between Jimmy and JT was 80pts...

[Rosenbluu]

I'd keep Julio - I'm not sold on Evans and who knows who that 2015 1st will be. JT is just a TE - the difference between him and Charles Clay last year was just 30 pts - the difference between Jimmy and JT was 80pts...

X2

[cowboysfan]

Thanks for the advice. I'm probably going to hang onto Julio.

[MEuRaH]

I think it's an even trade, so it's more about situation.

If you are in a 10 team league, keep Julio. Studs = winners.

If you are in a league where you are looking to make the playoffs this year, Julio side.

If you're in a rebuild, the other side. Your team won't fair too well, and you'll get a sweet 1st rounder next year.

[cowboysfan]

This a 16 team idp league. I also have Ball, Murray, and Michael at RB along with Foles at QB. My best guess is I will finish first or second in my division. The owner I'm n talks with May finish first in our division since he has Charles, lynch, RGIii, Julius. He is very interested in Michael though.

[dynastysports]

Julio for me and it's really not close at all.

[Bad News Barrett]

I think it's an even trade, so it's more about situation.

If you are in a 10 team league, keep Julio. Studs = winners.

If you are in a league where you are looking to make the playoffs this year, Julio side.

If you're in a rebuild, the other side. Your team won't fair too well, and you'll get a sweet 1st rounder next year.

Giving the Julio would make the other team better, making the pick later

[collbey]

If trading Julio, need to get a stud back. Especially with your team with 2 good development guys already in Patterson and Watkins.

[Shcritters]

Julio and not that close after thinking on it a while. I own Julius and think he is average at best once Peyton is gone. 2015 is a crapshoot, and if Evans turns out like the guy he is being compared to (Vincent Jackson) then he is a top 10-15 guy. Would need a guaranteed stud to get him away from me.