Would you Get Peyton if the was your team?

[ccarey23]

I am pretty sure I can get Peyton for my 2014 first. It is for my team below.

I love Luck, but I want to make a legit run at the Championship this year. I think Peyton might be what I am missing.

Thanks for the input.

[dlf_jules]

Hold onto your 1st. You may be able to make a run this year, but your team is built for the next 3+ -- Nicks, Julio, Dez, Blackmon, Luck, TRich. That's a high price to pay for Manning, anyhow, especially in a 10-teamer (and especially because QBs get double points for rushing TDs).

If you get halfway through the season and you feel like you're a QB away from winning it all, then you can make a move.

[voiceofunreason]

I am pretty sure I can get Peyton for my 2014 first. It is for my team below.

I love Luck, but I want to make a legit run at the Championship this year. I think Peyton might be what I am missing.

Thanks for the input.

Because you are so loaded everywhere, I don't think it's a bad idea. I love Luck but I think Peyton will outscore him by a decent bit this year. There's just a ton of talent on the Denver offense.

[carmo]

I mean how can you not just keep Luck,
First off: why not stay young and build for future has more value in it than trading for a 37 yr QB who might score a few more points than Luck
I mean you are trading a potential future stud for a 37 yr old QB who you dont need.. doesnt make sense not at all unless Luck gets hurt... how can you even be skeptical of Luck?

[mjreardon]

I think Manning could be a pretty decent upgrade over Luck in 2013, but now so much that it's worth a 1st round pick. 2nd? Sure. Not a 1st.

[thriftyrocker]

Trust Luck. Improve RB3 instead