McFadden or Murray?

[mzkp54]

PPR- who do you prefer?

[Team Tacos]

i like mcfadden > murray. can't give up on him yet. murray is hurt too much. it's weird to say that when comparing a player to mcfadden but i just don't think he's shown us enough.

[CokeAndBacardi]

Another thread featuring very popular running backs with no real question marks... ha.

I prefer McFadden to Murray. Looping in the other thread, I would rank the polarizing RBs as:

McFadden
Murray
Mathews
Stewart

[DAG]

I prefer DMC to Murray.

[BuckeyeNation]

I like DMC a little more than Murray but they are side by side in my RB rankings.

You want to talk about a headache as an owner, how about owning both of these guys on the same team. That would be me. They are my RB2-RB3 behind McCoy, but McCoy has concerns of his own now after the concussion. That's a RB core that is bound to give me heartburn.

[Eight7Seven]

Near the end of the season last year I made a trade including these two players. I traded DMC & Kenny Britt for DeMarco & Aaron Hernandez. At the time both were injured and I was very concerned that I was taking a hit at running back. At this moment I would still take Darren over DeMarco, but at this point I think its splitting hairs. I can't say with any degree of confidence which one of these players will stay healthy the longest, let alone have the bigger fantasy impact next season. Ether could turn into significant fantasy contributors on your team.

[Duffmanohno2003]

McFadden, I hope.

[KCLep20]

I like DMC a little more than Murray but they are side by side in my RB rankings.

You want to talk about a headache as an owner, how about owning both of these guys on the same team. That would be me. They are my RB2-RB3 behind McCoy, but McCoy has concerns of his own now after the concussion. That's a RB core that is bound to give me heartburn.

Ill tak ur headache at RB and raise u McFadden, Mathews, and JStew. Now that's a headache...