Thoughts on offer...

[FarNorthAK]

I get: Percy Harvin, W McGahee and Joe Haden
He gets: J McKnight, Torrey Smith, 1.07 and 3.10

His significant roster:

QB: Kolb, Moore, Palmer
RB: C Johnson, M Lynch, W McGahee, J Ringer, J Harper, C Ivory, L Washington
WR: DHB, Harvin, R White, M Williams, C Schillens, N Burleson, V Brown
TE: Witten, Daniels
1.04 pick

[DynastyFeed]

Is this something he offered or that you are thinking about offering TO him?

McKnight is worthless (imho), so this boils down to Torrey Smith and the 1.07 for Harvin and whatever McGahee has left in the tank.

In a 12 team PPR, Harvin>>>Smith. I'd do it.

[nation31]

I view Harvin as the most valuable player in the deal so I like it for you. The only thing of value that you really give up is Torrey Smith and 1.07 fall just outside the elite talent in the draft. for reference, I just traded Harvin Tate and 2 first round picks and a second for Gronk and SJAX,

[Pork Sword]

If you are thinking of offering, I doubt it gets accepted. But send it, and see what he counters with. If he offered you, accept fast!

[DynastyFeed]

If you are thinking of offering, I doubt it gets accepted. But send it, and see what he counters with. If he offered you, accept fast!

That's exactly what I was getting at...

[PackFan1]

If you can get his deal, definitely do it.

[FarNorthAK]

He offered it to me. Ill take it.

[Space Cowboy]

Harvin and Smith are close in value. Why would you have to include 1.07? McGahee is at the end of the line.

[DynastyFeed]

Harvin and Smith are close in value. Why would you have to include 1.07? McGahee is at the end of the line.

I disagree with this.

Harvin is worth WAY more in a PPR league (IMHO).

[olingeridp]

Harvin finished as the WR7 in PPR leagues last season. To me this is a no-brainer too. I like Torrey Smith but Harvin is special. McGahee is getting overlooked. He should be able to give you one decent season. I would do this deal.

[Space Cowboy]

Harvin and Smith are close in value. Why would you have to include 1.07? McGahee is at the end of the line.

I disagree with this.

Harvin is worth WAY more in a PPR league (IMHO).

Smith blew the top off of defenses and came in really raw. After 2 or 3 years, he could be something really special. Hes alot stronger than what I have him credit for, he'll probably end up being a good underneath threat if he works on his routes.

harvin is better, no doubt about that, but its a bridge gapped by a mid 2nd rounder/depth player if you ask me.

[lukeb]

I'd give up Smith and the 1.07 for Harvin in a cocaine heartbeat

[Pork Sword]

Harvin and Smith are close in value. Why would you have to include 1.07? McGahee is at the end of the line.

I disagree with this.

Harvin is worth WAY more in a PPR league (IMHO).

Smith blew the top off of defenses and came in really raw. After 2 or 3 years, he could be something really special. Hes alot stronger than what I have him credit for, he'll probably end up being a good underneath threat if he works on his routes.

harvin is better, no doubt about that, but its a bridge gapped by a mid 2nd rounder/depth player if you ask me.

I think smith is a nice player, but I see him as a deep threat and not much more. This leads to games where he has 30+ points and games with 2. He would always be on my bench for the big game and in the lineup for the 1 catch/13 yards. He has huge upside, but I'm not a fan of boom or bust wrs.