Give CMC to Get Najee + rookie r1p5 +?

[jobiegermano]

Signature is up-to-date with my core team, will add 7 more players via rookie draft and supplemental auction.

Chance to 3peat this year, but have zero rookie picks until ‘26 so team is at risk of aging out.

Give: CMC

Get: Najee + rookie r1p5
. (likely Thomas, Worthy, Brooks, or Bowers range)

Doesn’t seem like enough for the best player in the league, right? He also has the r1p1 but won’t come off it because he wants MHJ. Would maybe add other picks like r2p5 or maybe even a next year r1 or could try to get another player from his team added??

Thoughts?

[Prison_Mike]

10tm 1QB, I would hold rather easily

[jobiegermano]

10tm 1QB, I would hold rather easily

That’s my gut. Maybe if that r1p1 was included, but there’s basically 4 super teams and 4 crap rebuilding teams and 2 middle of the road teams, so even as stacked as my team feels, I have 3 others just as good as mine.

I do want Najee tho.

[Anteaters]

10tm 1QB, I would hold rather easily

++

[Prison_Mike]

10tm 1QB, I would hold rather easily

That’s my gut. Maybe if that r1p1 was included, but there’s basically 4 super teams and 4 crap rebuilding teams and 2 middle of the road teams, so even as stacked as my team feels, I have 3 others just as good as mine.

I do want Najee tho.

Why tho?

[jobiegermano]

I do want Najee tho.

Why tho?

Being a homer I have seen every game Najee has played and followed this offseason intently. This offense, offensive line, coaching philosophy, and published intent will be to run the ball using the same model as when Arthur Smith was the OC of the Titans in Derrick Henry’s prime.

I am *not* saying Najee will be the next King Henry, but he’s got 1000 yards every year of his career and now they will *start* to feature and support him! And he’ll have a competent QB whose best years were Seattle’s Beast Mode years.

I know I’m a homer. I know I’m looking at Najee through rose colored glasses, but that doesn’t mean it’s wrong either. Najee will be a top 10 RB next year IMO.

The fact they didn’t pick up his 5th year option feels like a negotiating point I can use too, but as a fan, I think he’ll get a long term contract.

[tstafford]

10tm 1QB, I would hold rather easily

That’s my gut. Maybe if that r1p1 was included, but there’s basically 4 super teams and 4 crap rebuilding teams and 2 middle of the road teams, so even as stacked as my team feels, I have 3 others just as good as mine.

I do want Najee tho.

Why tho?

While I'm not doing this deal, I too want Najee this year. Loss of Diontae could mean more targets and I think PIT runs him in to the ground on the last year of his deal.

[blemly]

That’s my gut. Maybe if that r1p1 was included, but there’s basically 4 super teams and 4 crap rebuilding teams and 2 middle of the road teams, so even as stacked as my team feels, I have 3 others just as good as mine.

I do want Najee tho.

Why tho?

While I'm not doing this deal, I too want Najee this year. Loss of Diontae could mean more targets and I think PIT runs him in to the ground on the last year of his deal.

League dependent disclaimer, but he has been going for cheap in some leagues I’m in. 2.06 in a 12-tm SF last week. People are way out, so it’s time to buy imo.

[TheTroll]

That’s my gut. Maybe if that r1p1 was included, but there’s basically 4 super teams and 4 crap rebuilding teams and 2 middle of the road teams, so even as stacked as my team feels, I have 3 others just as good as mine.

I do want Najee tho.

Why tho?

While I'm not doing this deal, I too want Najee this year. Loss of Diontae could mean more targets and I think PIT runs him in to the ground on the last year of his deal.

This is how I feel. Find a different way to get Najee

[jobiegermano]

This is how I feel. Find a different way to get Najee

I asked if something with Diggs and/or Monty was a place to start for another way into Najee and he said without CMC his team is set. I think playing hardball, but never know.

Maybe I’d give CMC for Saquon AND Najee (I’d like that 5th in there too lol) but I bet he takes offense to that offer if I made it, but honestly in our scoring last year CMC totaled about the exact same points as Saquon and Najee together

[kellysheroes]

Easy hold

[Black Adam]

In a shallow-a** league like this, I'm probably keeping CMC until the wheels fall off.

It's non-PPR and none of those guys at 1.05 excites me. Either get more, or hold. None of those rookies is making your team much better anyways.