Kyler+ for Herbert (poll)

[Hankybro21]

Team 3. 10tm SF

Give: Herbert
Get: Kyler + Jamo


Thoughts here? I like Herbert more, health especially, but I don’t love his situation at present and I’ve got MHJ here to stack with Kyler. I don’t expect much if anything out of jamo but who knows

[TheTroll]

Prob fair deal but keep Herbert. I just don’t trust Murray somehow.

[NathanielWegman]

I’m sticking with Herbert pretty easily in this scenario.

[Black Adam]

Whichever side does not have Jamo, so in this case, Herbert.

SN: I'm worried about Herbert in this Harbaugh offense so I'm out on him too.

[lukkynumber13]

Jameson Williams is worth like a mid-late 2nd IMO. Not a needle mover.

Give me Herbert easily.

[Hankybro21]

Thanks all

I have to admit that this is far more lopsided to the Herbert side than I expected

[Black Adam]

Thanks all

I have to admit that this is far more lopsided to the Herbert side than I expected

Not sure why, Kyler is clearly the inferior option at QB and "Jamo" has like 400 yards through his first 2 seasons, albeit he was coming off a major injury.

[Anteaters]

Jamo is useless on a contender.

Still, I have Kyler as a better QB than Herbert, so I'm on the Kyler side. I would not even trade Kyler for Herbert+Jamo.

But if you think Herbert is better than Kyler, then you should make the trade to get Herbert. Again, the Jamo piece is beneath the value to be considered in a trade of QBs in a SF league, so Jamo's inclusion should not affect your decision one iota.

[blemly]

This comes down to preference between the 2 QBs and Jamo can more or less be ignored entirely. I prefer Herbert.