Another Dell Offer

[Heartwork]

Get: Pick 1.08
Give: Dell

Straight up, who do you prefer?

[Stone2987]

Sf? I’d probably lean Dell but if you like McCarthy, 1.08 is the last pick of a fairly big tier drop for me. If 1 qb Dell for sure.

[Menace2010]

1QB Dell
SF 1.08

[Jrblaha]

Dell and it isn’t close in 1QB

[Anteaters]

Dell by 1 mile in SF
Dell by 3 miles in 1qb

[Needalife]

In SF, 1.08 easily for me. Dell is fun but I want the 4 QBs, 3 WRs, 1 TE and I think 1-2 RBs will sneak in with good landing spots.

In single QB, it’s closer but I’m still rolling the dice on something new. Dell had the bad injury and my concerns about his size remain. Great player though so I can’t fault those who prefer Dell too.

[BabyChark23]

In SF, 1.08 easily for me. Dell is fun but I want the 4 QBs, 3 WRs, 1 TE and I think 1-2 RBs will sneak in with good landing spots.

In single QB, it’s closer but I’m still rolling the dice on something new. Dell had the bad injury and my concerns about his size remain. Great player though so I can’t fault those who prefer Dell too.

X2.

[SoftwoodGrampian]

1.8

[TheTroll]

In SF, 1.08 easily for me. Dell is fun but I want the 4 QBs, 3 WRs, 1 TE and I think 1-2 RBs will sneak in with good landing spots.

In single QB, it’s closer but I’m still rolling the dice on something new. Dell had the bad injury and my concerns about his size remain. Great player though so I can’t fault those who prefer Dell too.

X2.

X3

[tstafford]

In SF, 1.08 easily for me. Dell is fun but I want the 4 QBs, 3 WRs, 1 TE and I think 1-2 RBs will sneak in with good landing spots.

In single QB, it’s closer but I’m still rolling the dice on something new. Dell had the bad injury and my concerns about his size remain. Great player though so I can’t fault those who prefer Dell too.

X2.

X3

I'm shocked y'all are saying they'd take the 1.08 over Dell in 1QB. I'm for sure "rolling the dice" on Dell vs. the unknown of what could be the WR5 or so in this class. I get that we like this class a ton but these guys have flaws too. We've seen Dell do it in the NFL.

In SF, I can see it. But no way in 1QB.

[BabyChark23]

X2.

X3

I'm shocked y'all are saying they'd take the 1.08 over Dell in 1QB. I'm for sure "rolling the dice" on Dell vs. the unknown of what could be the WR5 or so in this class. I get that we like this class a ton but these guys have flaws too. We've seen Dell do it in the NFL.

In SF, I can see it. But no way in 1QB.

I was mostly responding to the SF part of the comment. In SF, it’s 1.08 (Bowers/Cowboys new RB) for me and not remotely close. In 1QB, I can see it either way.

[BigBawseRoss]

its an sf but he wrote 1qb and slipped in an SF spot lol

id take 1.08 over dell but its a fair deal.

[Viking386]

Give me Dell for 1 QB

SF is close, Id lean the pick

[FiremanEd]

1QB will be Dell.

SF I’ll take 1.08, as it’s very possible a WR I prefer to him slips a spot following the draft, or depending on your league owners. I don’t think the worst case scenario does anything but leave you at even, but gain upside for a win.

[Anteaters]

1QB will be Dell.

SF I’ll take 1.08, as it’s very possible a WR I prefer to him slips a spot following the draft, or depending on your league owners. I don’t think the worst case scenario does anything but leave you at even, but gain upside for a win.

That's wildly optimistic for the 1.08 in SF.

In ppg, Dell finished anywhere between WR13-WR19 in his rookie season. And that's counting his final game where he was injured early and a zero was averaged in. Taking that out, Dell was solidly a WR1 by ppg.

If someone is seriously worried about his size, okay, go with your gut. But when it comes to talent+production, I doubt if anyone seriously expects any WR chosen at 1.08 in a SF draft to be as good as Dell was in 2023.