Kyren Williams Trade Offer

[ausmith26]

Give - Tua, 1.10, & 2025 3rd
Get - Kyren Williams

Value seems good and adds a young RB to pair with Bijan. Seems like a no brainer to me but wanted to get another opinion before accepting. Thanks!

[Black Adam]

Value seems fine but if I'm the Kyren owner I'm passing on that quite easily, especially in a shallow 1QB league.

[slaughterrt]

Hard to trade for a non-elite RB pre-draft. I would be hesitant about making a move for almost any RB right now.

[Shoreline Steamers]

Value seems fine but if I'm the Kyren owner I'm passing on that quite easily, especially in a shallow 1QB league.

If he's looking for opinions before accepting, that means it's on the table. He's got the Tua side.

Agree with holding off for now. I've been burned in the past by trading for RB's early in the offseason, only to see things go sideways. Though it's not a bad price if you're leaning toward taking the leap.

[ausmith26]

Hard to trade for a non-elite RB pre-draft. I would be hesitant about making a move for almost any RB right now.

Totally get the idea of waiting, but I am also a huge Rams fan haha. I was tempted to accept anyways until someone texted me offering Breece Hall for my 1.02 straight up.

Is that elite enough to trade for before the draft?

[Black Adam]

Value seems fine but if I'm the Kyren owner I'm passing on that quite easily, especially in a shallow 1QB league.

If he's looking for opinions before accepting, that means it's on the table. He's got the Tua side.

Yes, that is how trades work.

Said differently, since I don’t know who started the negotiation: Seems like a fair value but not a trade I would make if I was the other owner.

[Black Adam]

Is that elite enough to trade for before the draft?

While I think BH is good, I’m not crowning him “elite” before he breaks 1K and strings together more than 1 good season.

I’d call him a good foundational piece you could probably build around long-term though.

For me this also a push value-wise, so unless you are a Breece fan or think Breece >>> rook WR scoring-wise, I’d ask for more or simply hold.


I don’t think your RBs need more work than your WOs FWIW.

[Mtt33]

I would absolutely take the Williams trade in a 1qb. I’d take the breece trade in a 1qb as well.

[Shoreline Steamers]

Value seems fine but if I'm the Kyren owner I'm passing on that quite easily, especially in a shallow 1QB league.

If he's looking for opinions before accepting, that means it's on the table. He's got the Tua side.

Yes, that is how trades work.

Said differently, since I don’t know who started the negotiation: Seems like a fair value but not a trade I would make if I was the other owner.

Yep. I'm up to speed on how trades work. Point is, the underlined is irrelevant. The offer is on the table for the OP to accept or not. Said differently, "That's a steal for Kyren," if that's what you think (and it appears that is the case).

I will say, I agree with Black Adam looking at your roster. Your WR's do need more work than your RB's. With 1.01 and 1.02 you could grab MHJ and Nabers (or Odunze if that's more your preference). Get some projected "elite" youth at the position where you start 3 (versus 2 RB) and gain positional longevity.

Your RB's should be OK to carry you through this season, then you could look to add a RB in the 2025 class which projects to have better talent (or possibly at 1.10 depending on how your draft unfolds). Personal bias, but I always make sure I feel strong at WR and QB, then worry about filling RB's last since they generally give you fewer productive years.

And if you find yourself out of contention, look to sell some of your aging players (Henry, Evans, Hopkins, for example) for some future draft capital.

[Anteaters]

The Tua+1.10 kind of irks me on the surface, but it's a very good deal to get an elite RB in 1QB.

[TheTroll]

Kyren side pretty easy in 1QB. 1.10 is a crapshoot and Tua is more replaceable

[tstafford]

Kyren side pretty easy in 1QB. 1.10 is a crapshoot and Tua is more replaceable

x2.

[The.Big.Spank]

I would absolutely take the Williams trade in a 1qb. I’d take the breece trade in a 1qb as well.

Agree

[BigBawseRoss]

id prob make both deals thats adding 2 absolute hammers to your lineup. idk why everyone is so poopoo on kyren he and cmc were the only dudes getting projected for 20+ a week. he had 2 games all season without either 100+, a TD, or both

[pmart33]

I like the Kyren side in 1QB. Williams getting through free agency without a high profile RB landing in LA was huge for his 2024 value. The Rams will probably draft a back this year but there isn't one in this class that is going to relegate Williams to a backup role.