2024 Bad Trade Offers

[tstafford]

Woke up to this remarkable offer

Give: Ja’Marr Chase
Get: Terry McLaurin, Harrison Bryant

what are you waiting for????? @TSafford.... this is one for the trophy case

Could be the first time I've ever seen mention of Harrison Bryant on the forum! Incredible.

[CGW]

Give: ETN + 3.06
Get: Aaron Rodgers

I need a QB in the SF league, but man, in what world is Rodgers worth more than a song.

[Anteaters]

Give: ETN + 3.06
Get: Aaron Rodgers

I need a QB in the SF league, but man, in what world is Rodgers worth more than a song.

In the world of fantasy managers who believe he's the real-world QB that can lead the New York Jets to success. Many people apparently feel Rodgers would have been a fantasy star in 2023 if not for injury, and those people think he'll be a fantasy star in 2024. In that world of fantasy managers, this probably looks like a perfectly reasonable trade.

[remedy29]

Give: ETN + 3.06
Get: Aaron Rodgers

I need a QB in the SF league, but man, in what world is Rodgers worth more than a song.

In the world of fantasy managers who believe he's the real-world QB that can lead the New York Jets to success. Many people apparently feel Rodgers would have been a fantasy star in 2023 if not for injury, and those people think he'll be a fantasy star in 2024. In that world of fantasy managers, this probably looks like a perfectly reasonable trade.

Some of you all just play in bad, amature leagues. This trade is proof of nothing more than CGW is playing with people who don't know what they are doing. It has nothing to do with a group of people overly believing in Rodgers fantasy production or dynasty worth in 2024.

[Dynasty DeLorean]

Give: ETN + 3.06
Get: Aaron Rodgers

I need a QB in the SF league, but man, in what world is Rodgers worth more than a song.

It’s bad. And you can rationalize by saying ARod might give you 2-3 more years just like ETN might give you 2-3 more years. But the kicker is always when they throw the draft pick in on top, as if ETN by himself isn’t more than enough. lol.

[FantasyFreak]

Today I had someone ask me to give them a player for free. Wasn't a misclick.

Pretty sure that would be collusion. I'd actually inform the commish about that one.

[81-]

Today I had someone ask me to give them a player for free. Wasn't a misclick.

Pretty sure that would be collusion. I'd actually inform the commish about that one.

Even if said player was Harrison Bryant?

[TheTroll]

Today I had someone ask me to give them a player for free. Wasn't a misclick.

Pretty sure that would be collusion. I'd actually inform the commish about that one.

Even if said player was Harrison Bryant?

It’s not free if you need to drop someone.

[slaughterrt]

Pretty sure that would be collusion. I'd actually inform the commish about that one.

Even if said player was Harrison Bryant?

It’s not free if you need to drop someone.

Could certainly my plausible if salary/contracts are involved.

[FiremanEd]

16 team SF

Get: mid-2025 1st + mid-2025 2nd
Give: Jalen Hurts + Puka Nacua

But, I can swap Nacua for Breece Hall if I prefer…

[Bronco Billy]

Give: ETN + 3.06
Get: Aaron Rodgers

I need a QB in the SF league, but man, in what world is Rodgers worth more than a song.

This one is going to be worth monitoring. This very well may be a bad trade offer, but not for the reason that some above are gleefully pouncing on it. I’m extremely loath to dismiss Rodgers when he’s got a chip on his shoulder and feels he’s got something to prove.

[Bronco Billy]

16 team SF

Get: mid-2025 1st + mid-2025 2nd
Give: Jalen Hurts + Puka Nacua

But, I can swap Nacua for Breece Hall if I prefer…

Geez, maybe you ought to send both Nacua and Hall with Hurts just to make sure it’s fair.

[wickerkat1212]

On a scale of 1 to 10 with 10 being awful how bad is this trade offer I just got?
10/10 IMO.

Akers, Cam MIN RB
Foreman, D'Onta CLE RB
Year 2024 Draft Pick 3.10

for

Hill, Tyreek MIA WR

[killer_of_giants]

On a scale of 1 to 10 with 10 being awful how bad is this trade offer I just got?
10/10 IMO.

Akers, Cam MIN RB
Foreman, D'Onta CLE RB
Year 2024 Draft Pick 3.10

for

Hill, Tyreek MIA WR

it's bad, but not even the worst on this page.

[BabyChark23]

On a scale of 1 to 10 with 10 being awful how bad is this trade offer I just got?
10/10 IMO.

Akers, Cam MIN RB
Foreman, D'Onta CLE RB
Year 2024 Draft Pick 3.10

for

Hill, Tyreek MIA WR

it's bad, but not even the worst on this page.

Might make the top 10 list tho