Aaron Rodgers’ value in 2QB leagues?

[Riverad98]

12 team Dynasty 2QB 2TE league. Deep league with 13 starting spots and some crazy scoring.
WR = 1 PPR
RB = 1.5 PPR
TE = 2 PPR
.5 passing & rushing 1st downs. .25 receiving 1st downs.
3 point bonus for 40+ yard pass, rush or reception & 4 point bonus for 40+ pass, rush or reception TD.
QBs are high scoring with QB1s scoring 30-40 points per game. Rodgers is projected at 29 points per game.

How would you value Aaron Rodgers in this format? I have an offer of my Rodgers, Aaron Jones & Jonnu Smith for the 24 1.11 rookie pick & Dameon Pierce. I’m not really interested in Pierce but I do want the 1st. I may be able to get Jerry Jeudy instead of Pierce or get a throw in WR like Jalin Hyatt added. My team has a good young core in Mahomes, Achane, Ceedee, Waddle, Pitts & Kincaid. I also have the 1.04 pick. If I take the trade, I can take a QB at 1.04 and add a WR or RB at 1.11 plus getting some old players off my roster.. If I pass on the offer, I can keep Rodgers as my QB3, start Aaron Jones at a flex spot and then possibly get Nabers or Bowers at the 1.04. Not sure if I can trust having two old QBs as my QB2 and QB3 though.




Starting lineup: 2 QB, 2 RB, 3 WR, 2 TE & 4 flex.
QB: Mahomes, Stafford, Rodgers, Jimmy G, Winston, Wentz, Mariota, Zach Wilson
RB: Achane, Pollard, Aaron Jones, Sermon,Deuce, Penny, TDP
WR: Lamb, Waddle, Mike Williams, Tucker, Claypool, Melton, Iosivas,
TE: Kincaid, Pitts, Fant, Jonnu, Okonkwo, Logan Thomas, Turner
2024 1.04, 3.10, 3.11, 4.04, 5.04

[Menace2010]

That's a lot of production for a single 1st round pick. I'd try to sell Rodgers and Jones separately, a single 1st for both in a 2QB, 2RB, 4 Flex and PPC league seems too cheap.

[TheTroll]

I like the wait part. I’d agree the scoring is kinda crazy but definitely don’t give up that production all at ones. Rodgers has 1 last time to prove everyone. Ride it so far.

[Mtt33]

Can you get a future 2 or something instead? Value wise this isn’t awful, I know it’s 2 qb instead of SF but the extra starting spots and points boosts I think lower qb value back to around SF value.
That said I think you need a better sweetener, if you can get any type of 2 back it’s solid.

[SoftwoodGrampian]

Rodgers for 1.11 sounds right

[Menace2010]

Sure Rodgers for 1.11 is about right, maybe slightly overpaying so you add J. Smith to your side. The offer is both of them and A. Jones for 1.11, which is not enough for me. I'd want at least a 2nd added.

[Mtt33]

Who’s paying 1.11 for rodgers? Have you seen that value on your leagues? I havent seen anything close to this value in trades or startup adp but doesn’t mean it’s not happening.

[CGW]

I had someone offer me Rodgers for my ETN and a 2nd in a 2QB league. Clearly, that's not going to be helpful for any sane person attempting to gauge his value.

[Riverad98]

The other team has no other 2024 or 2025 picks which makes it harder to make a deal. He lost Fields as a starter so he needs a QB badly. He had sent me multiple offers for Rodgers & Jones but wanted to include Pitts or Achane who I am not interested in trading. I had countered with Rodgers & Jonnu for the 1.11 & Jeudy. He declined and then sent me the current offer. In this format, Jeudy and Jonnu have similar value. I’ll probably counter with Rodgers & Jonnu for the 1.11. If he doesn’t accept that, I’ll just keep Rodgers.

[wickerkat1212]

Offer seems right

[abloom]

Who’s paying 1.11 for rodgers? Have you seen that value on your leagues? I havent seen anything close to this value in trades or startup adp but doesn’t mean it’s not happening.

Are you playing in 12 team true 2qb leagues?

A first for just about any starting QB, especially one that can put up points is the going rate. Assuming that the team earned the 1.11 it makes even more sense.

[Mtt33]

Who’s paying 1.11 for rodgers? Have you seen that value on your leagues? I havent seen anything close to this value in trades or startup adp but doesn’t mean it’s not happening.

Are you playing in 12 team true 2qb leagues?

A first for just about any starting QB, especially one that can put up points is the going rate. Assuming that the team earned the 1.11 it makes even more sense.

Nope just SF for me, but with 13 starting spots and inflated scoring for the other positions, qb value should be somewhere around a typical Superflex I would think. This is a very deep league, I don’t see how you can boost qb value here, can’t imagine anyone giving up a first for rodgers when trying to fill out 11 non-qbs in a lineup.

[abloom]

Who’s paying 1.11 for rodgers? Have you seen that value on your leagues? I havent seen anything close to this value in trades or startup adp but doesn’t mean it’s not happening.

Are you playing in 12 team true 2qb leagues?

A first for just about any starting QB, especially one that can put up points is the going rate. Assuming that the team earned the 1.11 it makes even more sense.

Nope just SF for me, but with 13 starting spots and inflated scoring for the other positions, qb value should be somewhere around a typical Superflex I would think. This is a very deep league, I don’t see how you can boost qb value here, can’t imagine anyone giving up a first for rodgers when trying to fill out 11 non-qbs in a lineup.

SF doesn't require 2 starting QBs, 2 QB does. It's like the impact that a start 2 TE has compared to start 1 TE. Dramatic increase in cost. The fact that atleast 8 teams will be taking 2 zeroes during the year matters a lot.