Trade Advice ft: Stroud, 1.01…

[Nflnz]

For the team listed below SF 12 Team, PPR 4pt Passing TE, 0.5 TE Prem, the following trade is on the table.

Give: Stroud, Nico, Keaton Mitchell, 1.09
Get: 1.01, 1.05, David Njoku

Thoughts?


QB: Stroud, Kyler, Love, Cousins, Hooker
RB: White, Cook, Roschon, Warren, Herbert, Gainwell
WR: Nico, Metcalf, Dotson, Cooks, Williams, Mingo, Rondale
TE: Freirmuth, Schultz, Kmet

Picks
2024: 1.09, 2.09, 3.09
2025: 1st x4, 2nd, 3rd, 4th
2026: 1st x 2, 2nd, 3rd, 4th

[Menace2010]

Yuck

1.01 you can replace Stroud
1.05 you can replace Nico
Njoku <= 1.09
K. Mitchell is free... and that's assuming 1.01 and 1.05 actually hit.

[Anteaters]

I see what you're trying to do and I'm not 100% against it, but I hate to lose Stroud here. Also, Stroud and Nico are proven players at this point, while the rookies will have a big risk of not being as good as Stroud+Nico. If I did go through with the trade, I'd try very hard to keep the 1.09 and give the 2.09.

Right now this trade could be broken down to ...
1.09+Keaton for Njoku
Nico for 1.05
Stroud for 1.01

IMO, Stroud is worth much more than 1.01. Swapping the 1.09 for the 2.09 makes the trade a little easier to accept for me. Personally I still would not do the trade, but keeping the 1.09 makes it less bad for me.

[CGW]

No chance in hell. Stroud is worth the 1.01 and 1.05 alone. And you have to give up Nico and a 1st to get Njoku? Walk away brother.

[The.Big.Spank]

No chance in hell. Stroud is worth the 1.01 and 1.05 alone. And you have to give up Nico and a 1st to get Njoku? Walk away brother.

I was thinking the same thing. Stroud is worth more than the 1.01 and 1.05 to me.

[BigBawseRoss]

what is the point? genuinely asking. a qb for a qb a wr for a wr and then mitchell and a first for njoku which nobody would pay

[murphysxm]

No chance in hell. Stroud is worth the 1.01 and 1.05 alone. And you have to give up Nico and a 1st to get Njoku? Walk away brother.

This boils down to how much you believe in Caleb. I would rather have him over Stroud and 1.05 in SF, but I understand I am probably in the minority.

[mikedigs]

This is a gift wrapped Stroud + Nico package, at a bargain deal! I would hold those assets, unless the offer is over 50% greater in value than the current one.

The value might be close according to the trade calcs, but that's only the first part of the deal. The final part is what is the price on 2 already established assets in Stroud and Collins. Those picks may or may not hit. So def charge the buyer the "already established stud" fee.

[CGW]

No chance in hell. Stroud is worth the 1.01 and 1.05 alone. And you have to give up Nico and a 1st to get Njoku? Walk away brother.

This boils down to how much you believe in Caleb. I would rather have him over Stroud and 1.05 in SF, but I understand I am probably in the minority.

And I thought I was high on CW!

[murphysxm]

No chance in hell. Stroud is worth the 1.01 and 1.05 alone. And you have to give up Nico and a 1st to get Njoku? Walk away brother.

This boils down to how much you believe in Caleb. I would rather have him over Stroud and 1.05 in SF, but I understand I am probably in the minority.

And I thought I was high on CW!

Yeah, I am all in on him in a SF

[CGW]

This boils down to how much you believe in Caleb. I would rather have him over Stroud and 1.05 in SF, but I understand I am probably in the minority.

And I thought I was high on CW!

Yeah, I am all in on him in a SF

I'll get him in 3 of my 6 leagues as well..but man, if someone offered me Stroud for 1.01 I'd have a hard time not taking it.

[murphysxm]

And I thought I was high on CW!

Yeah, I am all in on him in a SF

I'll get him in 3 of my 6 leagues as well..but man, if someone offered me Stroud for 1.01 I'd have a hard time not taking it.

I didn't say I was right, just that I am all in!

[stpilots98]

This is a hard no for me. I would need more than 1.01 and 1.05 to move off of Stroud. As good as everyone says Caleb is, he's unproven and I can't move off of what CJ has shown in year one for him, unless it's a major overpay.