Should I trade J. Taylor for K. Murray? (6 point passing TD, 10 team SF) Edit: Counter-proposal made

[SteelLake]

QB RB RB WR WR TE FLEX FLEX SF

I’ve been trying for a full year to upgrade my qb2 and it keeps getting worse. I think owners seem to be valuing our qbs as 12 team league. One team has Murray as his qb3, debating offering the following, does it make sense:

I give:
J. Taylor

I get:
K. Murray

Big upgrade for me at qb, and I have walker, Pacheco, Olave to fill in for Taylor

Edited Proposal


I get:
K. Murray, 2.02 (12th overall)

I give:
J. Taylor, D. Watson

Hurts, Watson, R. Wilson
Gibbs, McCaffrey, Taylor, Walker, Pacheco, Miller, Rivers, Emmanuel Wilson
Chase, Lamb, Olave, Aiyuk , Downs, Mims, Wicks, Hyatt, W. Robinson, T. Palmer, M. Thomas, D. Robinson, Justyn Ross, B. Melton, D. Slay, X. Hutchinson, Gibpson
Kittle, Thomas

Draft picks:
1.10, 3.03, 3.06, 3.08, 9th pick of Round 4 until draft over
Late, 2025 1st; My 2025 1st; 4 2025 3rd's (all my picks after 3rd round, draft continues until end)

[Menace2010]

I'd try to get a pick upgrade back with this. I'd prefer Taylor in this size league, but given your dilemma and team make-up this trade makes sense.

[meineymoe]

Looking at team build and need, this might be the deal you'll have to make.
I agree with sneaking a draft pick upgrade in there, but if they take that out, you still need to do this swap.

Good luck!
-oo-

[TheTroll]

I like this deal for you. I bet the other owner will like it too. JT is solid value for a QB3. I would agree with a pick swap addition and play the 10team studs rule card and JT is that stud.

[Gator Sens]

This deal improves your build overall. QBs take a hit value wise in a 10 teamer, but the 6 points for all TDs boosts them a bit more. Fair both ways based on your build with the value possibly still being with Taylor.

[tstafford]

I definitely want Kyler. Any way you could send Watson back and get something added in return?

[SteelLake]

I definitely want Kyler. Any way you could send Watson back and get something added in return?

Sounds like might be requirement; see edited proposal:

I give Taylor, Watson; I get Murray, 2.02 (10 team league).

[SteelLake]

I like this deal for you. I bet the other owner will like it too. JT is solid value for a QB3. I would agree with a pick swap addition and play the 10team studs rule card and JT is that stud.

Curious of your thoughts on edited proposal

[SteelLake]

This deal improves your build overall. QBs take a hit value wise in a 10 teamer, but the 6 points for all TDs boosts them a bit more. Fair both ways based on your build with the value possibly still being with Taylor.

Curious of your thoughts on edited proposal

[SteelLake]

Looking at team build and need, this might be the deal you'll have to make.
I agree with sneaking a draft pick upgrade in there, but if they take that out, you still need to do this swap.

Good luck!
-oo-

Curious of your thoughts on edited proposal

[SteelLake]

I'd try to get a pick upgrade back with this. I'd prefer Taylor in this size league, but given your dilemma and team make-up this trade makes sense.

Curious of your thoughts on edited proposal

[Menace2010]

I'd have zero interest in the edited proposal. If you're saying QBs are so difficult to trade for in this league that you need to send Taylor for Murray, then Watson is way more valuable than 2.09. Would also want to have 3QBs in a league like that given what you've told us. Maybe swap Wilson for Watson.

[Gator Sens]

This deal improves your build overall. QBs take a hit value wise in a 10 teamer, but the 6 points for all TDs boosts them a bit more. Fair both ways based on your build with the value possibly still being with Taylor.

Curious of your thoughts on edited proposal

I can't stand Watson and would not have him in any format, but this is not the deal to move him in based on the return.

[SteelLake]

I'd have zero interest in the edited proposal. If you're saying QBs are so difficult to trade for in this league that you need to send Taylor for Murray, then Watson is way more valuable than 2.09. Would also want to have 3QBs in a league like that given what you've told us. Maybe swap Wilson for Watson.

Got him to switch it to 2.02... So:

Murray and 12th overall for JT and Watson.

I think I'm a yes now... wondering if I'm crazy though

[SteelLake]

This deal improves your build overall. QBs take a hit value wise in a 10 teamer, but the 6 points for all TDs boosts them a bit more. Fair both ways based on your build with the value possibly still being with Taylor.

Curious of your thoughts on edited proposal

I can't stand Watson and would not have him in any format, but this is not the deal to move him in based on the return.

Got him to switch it to 2.02... So:

Murray and 12th overall for JT and Watson.

I think I'm a yes now... wondering if I'm crazy though