AJ Brown Trade

[youknowme]

12 team SuperFlex PPR

Give: AJ Brown + Jameson Williams
Get: Amon-Ra St. Brown

I’m just have a gut feeling AJ is at his peak and Jameson is a bust. Would you do this if am I insane?

[frerichs5]

I wouldn’t do it, but I don’t think it’s insane. I have AJB and ARSB close together and wouldn’t really want to add anything to either one for the other.

If you like ARSB much better, I don’t think Jameson is a crazy price to pay (because I don’t really believe in him either).

[Gator Sens]

Preference deal. Both WRs are elite and not that he is a huge add, but one for one is fair. Williams on top is too much. At least he started to be involved as the season moved along.

[tstafford]

I don't think you should be adding to AJB. But given your POV, I guess it's not atrocious.

[TheTroll]

ARSB is the piece here but only by a smidge. It’s a toss up. I’d honestly make this a pick’em 1:1

[Tvols]

even at a bust do you thow away an asset u might get something for? I either remove jameson or ask for an add on from his side.

[moishetreats]

I'd much rather have ARSB than AJB. Easily.

For 2024, I'd rather have ARSB.
For 2025, I'd rather have ARSB.
For 2026 (when we really have to worry about AJB's body breaking down), I'd much rather have ASRB.

I'd EASILY give up Jameson for all those years where I'd rather have ARSB. (Plus, we seem to always underappreciate the value of a roster spot...)

[TheKraken]

I'd much rather have ARSB than AJB. Easily.

For 2024, I'd rather have ARSB.
For 2025, I'd rather have ARSB.
For 2026 (when we really have to worry about AJB's body breaking down), I'd much rather have ASRB.

I'd EASILY give up Jameson for all those years where I'd rather have ARSB. (Plus, we seem to always underappreciate the value of a roster spot...)

I agree with this. I would make this trade even with Williams.

[BigBawseRoss]

totally fine trade