2023 In Season Trades

[TheTroll]

Appreciate the positive feedback. Now do Kupp vs Wilson?

Kupp >>> M Wilson

Maybe one too few >'s.

[Jigga94]

Kincaid >> Engram

Appreciate the positive feedback. Now do Kupp vs Wilson?

Kupp >>> Wilson, but I like the overall deal for a rebuild. Studs should get more in return, but sometimes you have to settle for what you can get, especially if its affecting your draft position

[hoos89]

Kincaid >> Engram

Appreciate the positive feedback. Now do Kupp vs Wilson?

Kupp >>> Wilson, but I like the overall deal for a rebuild. Studs should get more in return, but sometimes you have to settle for what you can get, especially if its affecting your draft position

Also if Kupp has a 4th straight single digit game and Kincaid has another 15+ game this week, some people are going to start valuing Kincaid more than Kupp. Heck KTC already does that so I guess there must be some who already do (but obviously take those rankings with a grain of salt). Tbh I don't think it's crazy to prefer Kincaid to Kupp straight up in a rebuild, and the only real question is whether you can get more for Kupp from a different owner, which OP was unable to do. Engram and Mike Wilson are a wash in a vacuum, and I'd prefer Mike Wilson in a rebuild. This is a perfectly defensible deal, especially if it helps OP get MHJ.

[wickerkat1212]

In Dynasty #3 where I have Henry, I was offered Spears for Puka. Normally I'd pass, but with his QB injury and the fact that my WRs are pretty deep—Lamb, Diggs, DJM, Olave, Puka, Downs—maybe I should take it?

I could counter with Edwards/Downs for Spears/XXX.

Thoughts?

[Menace2010]

In Dynasty #3 where I have Henry, I was offered Spears for Puka. Normally I'd pass, but with his QB injury and the fact that my WRs are pretty deep—Lamb, Diggs, DJM, Olave, Puka, Downs—maybe I should take it?

I could counter with Edwards/Downs for Spears/XXX.

Thoughts?

No. And not particularly close... Puka >> Spears. Edwards is producing so unless you're rebuilding no reason to move him for a handcuff that is unlikely to produce like Henry were he to go down. And if you're rebuilding, you should actively shop Henry not Puka.

[wickerkat1212]

In Dynasty #3 where I have Henry, I was offered Spears for Puka. Normally I'd pass, but with his QB injury and the fact that my WRs are pretty deep—Lamb, Diggs, DJM, Olave, Puka, Downs—maybe I should take it?

I could counter with Edwards/Downs for Spears/XXX.

Thoughts?

No. And not particularly close... Puka >> Spears. Edwards is producing so unless you're rebuilding no reason to move him for a handcuff that is unlikely to produce like Henry were he to go down. And if you're rebuilding, you should actively shop Henry not Puka.

I was just thinking that Henry is starting to slow down and Spears may be the future. Spears went at 2.08 and I took Puka at 4.08. With Puka's QB issues, I worry that until Stafford comes back he'll underperform. Didn't somebody say Stafford was a "king-maker" when it comes to QBs? He's 35, Stafford.

[Jigga94]

Even if Puka regressed he will still be more valuable than Spears. Even if I thought Spears could be more valuable, I'd want a lot on top to make that deal

[Dynasty DeLorean]

In Dynasty #3 where I have Henry, I was offered Spears for Puka. Normally I'd pass, but with his QB injury and the fact that my WRs are pretty deep—Lamb, Diggs, DJM, Olave, Puka, Downs—maybe I should take it?

I could counter with Edwards/Downs for Spears/XXX.

Thoughts?

No. And not particularly close... Puka >> Spears. Edwards is producing so unless you're rebuilding no reason to move him for a handcuff that is unlikely to produce like Henry were he to go down. And if you're rebuilding, you should actively shop Henry not Puka.

I was just thinking that Henry is starting to slow down and Spears may be the future. Spears went at 2.08 and I took Puka at 4.08. With Puka's QB issues, I worry that until Stafford comes back he'll underperform. Didn't somebody say Stafford was a "king-maker" when it comes to QBs? He's 35, Stafford.

Yeah, how did that work out with Tony Pollard. Maybe Spears hits big, maybe he doesn’t. He probably doesn’t.

[mild]

I was just thinking that Henry is starting to slow down and Spears may be the future. Spears went at 2.08 and I took Puka at 4.08. With Puka's QB issues, I worry that until Stafford comes back he'll underperform. Didn't somebody say Stafford was a "king-maker" when it comes to QBs? He's 35, Stafford.

Men would rather trade away record-setting all-time Rookie WR's than go to therapy.

#sad

[wickerkat1212]

I was just thinking that Henry is starting to slow down and Spears may be the future. Spears went at 2.08 and I took Puka at 4.08. With Puka's QB issues, I worry that until Stafford comes back he'll underperform. Didn't somebody say Stafford was a "king-maker" when it comes to QBs? He's 35, Stafford.

Men would rather trade away record-setting all-time Rookie WR's than go to therapy.

#sad

LOL okay, damn, some Puka believers in here. I'll see if I can make another trade work.

[jcc6fd]

I was just thinking that Henry is starting to slow down and Spears may be the future. Spears went at 2.08 and I took Puka at 4.08. With Puka's QB issues, I worry that until Stafford comes back he'll underperform. Didn't somebody say Stafford was a "king-maker" when it comes to QBs? He's 35, Stafford.

Men would rather trade away record-setting all-time Rookie WR's than go to therapy.

#sad

LOL okay, damn, some Puka believers in here. I'll see if I can make another trade work.

Related trade I just completed involving Spears. 10 team league SF, HPPR. I am a competitor trading with a team missing the playoffs

I give: Spears, 2024 1st (likely late)
Receive: Kamara 2024 2nd (likely early)

I like Spears plenty (drafted him 22nd overall), but he’s not worth anything close to Puka.

[wickerkat1212]

Men would rather trade away record-setting all-time Rookie WR's than go to therapy.

#sad

LOL okay, damn, some Puka believers in here. I'll see if I can make another trade work.

Related trade I just completed involving Spears. 10 team league SF, HPPR. I am a competitor trading with a team missing the playoffs

I give: Spears, 2024 1st (likely late)
Receive: Kamara 2024 2nd (likely early)

I like Spears plenty (drafted him 22nd overall), but he’s not worth anything close to Puka.

Thanks. I guess I keep thinking that he's a 4th round / WW pick who has defied the odds. Guess I better give him more respect.

[lukkynumber13]

Team E
Sold Nuk, a 2nd, and a 3rd for Pollard

It’s more than I wanted to pay.
But I wanted another RB and I don’t think it’s Pollard’s fault he hasn’t been able to cash in on some of these goofy gamescripts Dallas has been in. Sometimes bad TD luck just exists, and that’s what I’m telling myself at least

[MacDaddy123]

In Dynasty #3 where I have Henry, I was offered Spears for Puka. Normally I'd pass, but with his QB injury and the fact that my WRs are pretty deep—Lamb, Diggs, DJM, Olave, Puka, Downs—maybe I should take it?

I could counter with Edwards/Downs for Spears/XXX.

Thoughts?

No. And not particularly close... Puka >> Spears. Edwards is producing so unless you're rebuilding no reason to move him for a handcuff that is unlikely to produce like Henry were he to go down. And if you're rebuilding, you should actively shop Henry not Puka.

I was just thinking that Henry is starting to slow down and Spears may be the future. Spears went at 2.08 and I took Puka at 4.08. With Puka's QB issues, I worry that until Stafford comes back he'll underperform. Didn't somebody say Stafford was a "king-maker" when it comes to QBs? He's 35, Stafford.

Those numbers mean absolutely nothing right now.
ARich and Bryce were both drafted ahead of Stroud, but Stroud is worth both of them right now, maybe even both together.

Draft capital only means something until further evidence is revealed, meaning games played.
Further evidence will change values accordingly.

Tyreek Hill and Stefon Diggs were both 5th round picks in the NFL Draft.
Do you think fantasy managers look down on them now because they were not 1st round picks? No.

[wickerkat1212]

No. And not particularly close... Puka >> Spears. Edwards is producing so unless you're rebuilding no reason to move him for a handcuff that is unlikely to produce like Henry were he to go down. And if you're rebuilding, you should actively shop Henry not Puka.

I was just thinking that Henry is starting to slow down and Spears may be the future. Spears went at 2.08 and I took Puka at 4.08. With Puka's QB issues, I worry that until Stafford comes back he'll underperform. Didn't somebody say Stafford was a "king-maker" when it comes to QBs? He's 35, Stafford.

Those numbers mean absolutely nothing right now.
ARich and Bryce were both drafted ahead of Stroud, but Stroud is worth both of them right now, maybe even both together.

Draft capital only means something until further evidence is revealed, meaning games played.
Further evidence will change values accordingly.

Tyreek Hill and Stefon Diggs were both 5th round picks in the NFL Draft.
Do you think fantasy managers look down on them now because they were not 1st round picks? No.

Good points. I guess I'm just not 100% sold on Puka being elite, but I could be wrong. He's certainly been amazing this year. I'm not the only person who has been surprised.