which side

[hord]

team in sig.

give kupp, jamo, jacobs, cousins, carr

get puka, dj moore, achane, stroud, bixby

[Anteaters]

Stroud side.

[fleaflickerchamp]

I dont find this remotely close you are robbing this man. You could argue you're getting the three best players of the deal with Stroud, Puka, and Achane

[Gator Sens]

I don't like moving two QBs in a deal in SF, but with Cousins done for the year and at his age, an unknown time table, I think you make the deal. This may be moving Kupp a bit early too, but there are a lot of what ifs on the side you are moving. I still prefer Kupp to Nacua despite two bad weeks and Achane is a wait and see for me. This is not a lopsided for me, but the young QB in Stroud is likely to have huge value this offseason while Cousins and Carr continue to go the other way.

[hord]

I dont find this remotely close you are robbing this man. You could argue you're getting the three best players of the deal with Stroud, Puka, and Achane

so you have puka over kupp already at this stage?

[fleaflickerchamp]

I dont find this remotely close you are robbing this man. You could argue you're getting the three best players of the deal with Stroud, Puka, and Achane

so you have puka over kupp already at this stage?

I said you could argue I'm not necessarily sure I would haha tbh I'm not as big on either as other people are but the age gap definitely means something with Kupp's injuries and simply being on an aging team (Stafford) where Mcvays devotion has been questioned. Seeing Puka's success has made me feel that although Kupp is a stud his elite status comes from the system of 20 targets he gets from Mcvay/Stafford. I didnt give a good look at OP's team but it looks like he should be contending (I assumed he wasnt because was acquiring all young players) in which I would still rather have Kupp. Regardless I like Stroud as the significantly best piece here and think sending all 5 for him is a closer deal than this one.

[hord]

I dont find this remotely close you are robbing this man. You could argue you're getting the three best players of the deal with Stroud, Puka, and Achane

so you have puka over kupp already at this stage?

I said you could argue I'm not necessarily sure I would haha tbh I'm not as big on either as other people are but the age gap definitely means something with Kupp's injuries and simply being on an aging team (Stafford) where Mcvays devotion has been questioned. Seeing Puka's success has made me feel that although Kupp is a stud his elite status comes from the system of 20 targets he gets from Mcvay/Stafford. I didnt give a good look at OP's team but it looks like he should be contending (I assumed he wasnt because was acquiring all young players) in which I would still rather have Kupp. Regardless I like Stroud as the significantly best piece here and think sending all 5 for him is a closer deal than this one.

i am the OP haha. and yes very much contending. pretty stacked really. 1st at 7-1 and highest scorer. lost in finals last year. but im always trying to stay younger if i can so thats why im considering trying to move kupp and jacobs... my main goal really was to move jacobs for achane. i dont see myself using jacobs much this year as i have barkely etienne and taylor, even montgomery when hes back id have above jacobs...

[BucBuc]

Not close my lord

[hord]

Not close my lord

if i remove DJ moore, and add a pick?

[BellCow]

I dont find this remotely close you are robbing this man. You could argue you're getting the three best players of the deal with Stroud, Puka, and Achane

so you have puka over kupp already at this stage?

In dynasty definitely

[TheTroll]

Puka