Ant Rich, Gibbs, or Devonta Smith?

[diamonddave]

We're in a semi-startup for a 2QB, 1PPR league where each team kept 5 players from their previous team. Bijan went #1 and I'm on the clock at Pick 2 and then pick again at #8. My keepers are Mahomes, Kyler, Saquon, Kupp and Chase. How would you advise I rank these players who are available in the draft?

Devonta Smith
Anthony Richardson
Jahmyr Gibbs
Bryce Young
Rhamondre Stevenson
Ken Walker III
TJ Hockenson

[Gator Sens]

2 QBs plays a factor but I would still go Smith here. He is a great WR and a high end asset. Richardson has a huge ceiling but an ify floor.

[BellCow]

I agree with going Smith here. Your build looks like it wants to compete now and Smith accomplishes that the most while being young enough.

[Bennyblanco22]

I'm not sure about arich by any means, but he's the best value in a 2qb assuming it's not an 8 team.

Edit: I see you kept 2 qbs. It's a 12team right? So I'd still definitely take arich even if you have 99% certainty you want to trade him.

[Anteaters]

Devonta now.
QB next (probably.)
If it's not TEP, no need to rush Hock or any TE.

[diamonddave]

2 QBs plays a factor but I would still go Smith here. He is a great WR and a high end asset. Richardson has a huge ceiling but an ify floor.

I kept Kyler but will definitely need someone in the meantime and Rich is tempting but I really would like to hit on my first pick. There are guys like Geno, Goff, Stafford, Howell, Pickett, A-Rod available as stopgaps later and a chance Bryce Young is available at #8. Do you recommend going with him or waiting for one of the others?

[diamonddave]

Devonta now.
QB next (probably.)
If it's not TEP, no need to rush Hock or any TE.

I'm hoping Young is there at 1.8 but there are also vets who'll be available later. Think he's worth that pick?

[diamonddave]

I'm not sure about arich by any means, but he's the best value in a 2qb assuming it's not an 8 team.

Edit: I see you kept 2 qbs. It's a 12team right? So I'd still definitely take arich even if you have 99% certainty you want to trade him.

Yes, 12 team. As I'm sure is the case w/everyone, the upside is dreamy but the downside is painful to think about. Haha

[Anteaters]

Devonta now.
QB next (probably.)
If it's not TEP, no need to rush Hock or any TE.

I'm hoping Young is there at 1.8 but there are also vets who'll be available later. Think he's worth that pick?

Young would be a great 3rd QB for you to take a 1.8.
Mahomes/Kyler/Young is a great 3qb lineup.