Pittman/Aiyuk/Goedert for picks?

[Badgersfan222]

I’m a middling team and trying to rebuild. I’m torn on dart throws.

12 team PPR/SF/1.75 TEP

I send: Aiyuk, Goedert, & Pittman
I get: 1.6, 1.7, 1.8, 2.3 & 2024 1st


QB- Kyler, Lance, Love, Henicke, & Jimmy G
RB- Breece, Hunt, K. Herbert
WR- Jeudy, Burks, Pittman, Devonta, Aiyuk
TE- Goedert, Kmet, Gesicki

[Gator Sens]

I think the value is close overall but that is not the pick range I would be excited about. Not a bad return, but I would keep shopping.

All pieces you are moving are better options than the prospects most likely to be available with the picks.

[Badgersfan222]

I felt the same

[frerichs5]

I’m not really a fan of this. None of the picks are super high. Unless that 2024 1st is projected real early, I think you’d be lucky to just replace these 3 out of those picks.

[mzkp54]

Yeah- I think I'd either package for a higher pick or hold. You're moving young players that are basically who you'd hope those picks turn in to. Goedert especially should be able to net a nice return with that TEP.

[Anteaters]

For the love of Joe Willie Namath, HOLD!

[TheTroll]

For the love of Joe Willie Namath, HOLD!

Lol!!! But true!

[greenbird]

This is Superflex so I would take those picks.

[Edgy68]

This is Superflex so I would take those picks.

I also was surprised at the responses saying the picks weren’t great. 3 or 4 QBs should be selected early enough to make those like the 1.03-1.05 in 1QB. I do agree you’d want picks to turn into young players like the ones you’re sending, but there are enough picks to add more shots at starters. I would be a bit sad to see Goedert go with that premium, but the WRs haven’t looked irreplaceable just yet and you have other good young options.

I would look to trade each pick separately otc so you know who’s available, just to see what you could get. If you could turn each into a developing young player and/or more 2024 1sts, that might help accelerate your rebuild and keep your 2024 1st early. I also would try to trade Kyler and Lance (if you can get a decent price) and K. Herbert over Goedert and maybe Pittman. If you could down-tier to an ascending QB like Fields or an earlier 1st or two, that would take some future risk out of the build.