Potential Restart the Clock Offer

[TheTroll]

Team 1 in sig. while I have been dominate I finished 4th this season and thinking about retooling. I’m in discussions with the 1.01 owner. Here is what I’m proposing


Give: Swift, Chubb, Justin Herbert, J Johnson
Get: 1.01, 2.01, Trevor Lawrence and Freiermuth.

Anyone this is this lopsided?

[BigBawseRoss]

1.01 side pretty easily for me

[Gator Sens]

This will come down to how the other manager views Swift and Chubb. I don't think it's a terrible offer but the addition of Lawrence even in a 1 QB format may be too much on top. The 1.01 is so valuable this year, that it will take a major overpay in most leagues.

[TheTroll]

This will come down to how the other manager views Swift and Chubb. I don't think it's a terrible offer but the addition of Lawrence even in a 1 QB format may be too much on top. The 1.01 is so valuable this year, that it will take a major overpay in most leagues.

I’m giving up Justin Herbert for the record

[Gator Sens]

This will come down to how the other manager views Swift and Chubb. I don't think it's a terrible offer but the addition of Lawrence even in a 1 QB format may be too much on top. The 1.01 is so valuable this year, that it will take a major overpay in most leagues.

I’m giving up Justin Herbert for the record

I was think Khalil Herbert, thanks for clearing that up. I think that makes it much closer. I still think an overpay will be needed and this will be very manager dependent but I don't think the offer is bad.

[Needalife]

This one is even IMO.

Herbert=Trevor
Chubb/Swift=1.01/2.01
Johnson=Freiermuth

I think there is a slight value nod toward the established guys but it's an even deal. I'd prefer Trevor side slightly since you are retooling.

[frerichs5]

This one is even IMO.

Herbert=Trevor
Chubb/Swift=1.01/2.01
Johnson=Freiermuth

I think there is a slight value nod toward the established guys but it's an even deal. I'd prefer Trevor side slightly since you are retooling.

You have J Johnson = Freiermuth? Not arguing, just haven’t seen anyone with that opinion before.

I’d rather have the 1.01 side. And don’t see it as particularly close either. For me:

Herbert = Lawrence
Johnson << Freiermuth
Swift > 2.01 (Though not by much in a 10 teamer.)
Chubb <<<<< 1.01

[starplatinum]

The 1.01 side is the winner in my eyes. Pretty much for the same reasons as mentioned above.

[MacDaddy123]

This will come down to how the other manager views Swift and Chubb. I don't think it's a terrible offer but the addition of Lawrence even in a 1 QB format may be too much on top. The 1.01 is so valuable this year, that it will take a major overpay in most leagues.

I’m giving up Justin Herbert for the record

Right, but it is a 10 team 1 QB league where QB's have very little value, and you are getting back TLaw who had a better 2022 season anyway.

The basic trade here is Swift and Chubb for 1.01 and 2.01.
Like Gator said much of it will depend on how the other manager views Swift and Chubb here.

Personally, I would want the 1.01 side here by quite a bit.
In fact, take off the 2.01, and I would still take the 1.01 side.

If you can make this trade, more power to you, you win!

[TheTroll]

This will come down to how the other manager views Swift and Chubb. I don't think it's a terrible offer but the addition of Lawrence even in a 1 QB format may be too much on top. The 1.01 is so valuable this year, that it will take a major overpay in most leagues.

I’m giving up Justin Herbert for the record

Right, but it is a 10 team 1 QB league where QB's have very little value, and you are getting back TLaw who had a better 2022 season anyway.

The basic trade here is Swift and Chubb for 1.01 and 2.01.
Like Gator said much of it will depend on how the other manager views Swift and Chubb here.

Personally, I would want the 1.01 side here by quite a bit.
In fact, take off the 2.01, and I would still take the 1.01 side.

If you can make this trade, more power to you, you win!

Ok so the other owner just proposed this offer:

Give: Swift, Chubb, Jawan Johnson
Get: 1.01, 3.01

He took the QBs out of the equation. He does have 2.01 and Mattison maybe change offer to include Mattison or swap 3.01 for 2.01 or should I just overpay and smash accept??? Thoughts?

[TheTroll]

Ok so the other owner just proposed this offer:

Give: Swift, Chubb, Jawan Johnson
Get: 1.01, 3.01

He took the QBs out of the equation. He does have 2.01 and Mattison maybe change offer to include Mattison or swap 3.01 for 2.01 or should I just overpay and smash accept??? Thoughts?

[Cherokee]

Ok so the other owner just proposed this offer:

Give: Swift, Chubb, Jawan Johnson
Get: 1.01, 3.01

He took the QBs out of the equation. He does have 2.01 and Mattison maybe change offer to include Mattison or swap 3.01 for 2.01 or should I just overpay and smash accept??? Thoughts?

Take it how it is

[TheTroll]

Deal completed. I countered and he accepted:

Gave: Swift, Chubb, J Johnson, 2.09, 4.08

Got: Friersmuth, 1.01, 2.01

[Big Al]

I would have done it without the counter. Sometimes counters can be risky, well done.

[TheTroll]

This is where you know your owners… he doesn’t mind a small attachment to a deal as long as the core is there for him