Andrews for ekeler

[cvbuc]

I would not assume Kelce in that offense and with that QB won't last several more years. I remember people starting to talk about selling him two years ago.

[hoos89]

I would not assume Kelce in that offense and with that QB won't last several more years. I remember people starting to talk about selling him two years ago.

People typically start talking about selling players (and their value starts to take an age hit) before their production actually falls off a cliff. He's 33...that's actually pretty old. I'd be shocked if Kelce puts up 3+ more elite seasons after this. Andrews should be favored to outscore Kelce in every season from '23 until Andrews retires.

[hord]

I like the Andrews and Chase package if it is an option but I don't see that deal going through. I prefer Andres long term to Ekeler straight up in the original deal but I think it will hurt this year a bit. Ekeler will likely pile up numbers based on his receiving floor, but long term this is easily Andrews.

what if it was kelce instead of andrews...
he asked if i would do ekeler and hopkins for kelce and white

[hord]

That's true in redraft, but in dynasty Andrews and Kelce is at least on the same tier as Kelce given that Andrews is 6 years younger and I personally would prefer Andrews on any roster except for a contender with a window closing this season or next.

Also Swift has never had a season even close to CMC's or Barkley's peak seasons so I don't think it's fair to compare him to them. Yes he's talented and yes his value is depressed by injuries and lack of usage but he's also never really sustained elite production. Better comparison would be someone like Dobbins or Javonte Williams....or to an extent Najee (who is also ostensibly healthy right now and has not been producing). Yes you might regret selling him now, but he also might be worth less in a year.

this is where i am struggling. i am a strong contender, but i also feel i am in a bit of a unique scenario where my window isnt neccesarily closing anytime soon... im also very young, so i could be strong for a while. i think kelce would help me more this year, but for how much longer... and kelce for sure would cost me ekeler.... andrews im not sure yet, still working stuff out... but prob needs ekeler as well... i can decide which one i want