Breece Hall thread (1.01)

[zacharyringer12]

Knowing what we know now about the injury, if your currently coming out of a rebuild and trying to compete come 2023, would you rather have Nick Chubb or Breece Hall?

On the flip side, if you are a top team this year, who would you be willing to trade Breece Hall for?

[Mjvb5]

Knowing what we know now about the injury, if your currently coming out of a rebuild and trying to compete come 2023, would you rather have Nick Chubb or Breece Hall?

On the flip side, if you are a top team this year, who would you be willing to trade Breece Hall for?

Hall over Chubb for me.
Players I'd swap hall for JT, swift, walker, bijan, barkley
Maybe maybe cmc

[Anteaters]

I don't have any shares of Breece, but if I did I'd be happy with a '23 1st for him. A 1st+ would be a bonus. If I'm a top team this year, I assume there are other top-shelf RBs on my roster. I wouldn't want to be without one of my top RBs for 1.5 seasons and Hope he comes back fully healthy, and Hope MCarter doesn't start putting up 100yd/1TD games on the regular. Not when I can get a good young piece in return that I can use to keep my machine rolling in 2023.

I know this is going to be sacrilege to Breece-believers. However, when I heard there was meniscus damage to go along with the ACL, my hopes for a swift total rehab went down a little. There is significant risk in holding and Hoping, especially if a 1st+ is offered.

[murphysxm]

Hall over Chubb for me.
Players I'd swap hall for JT, swift, walker, bijan, barkley

Good luck getting this return for him. I am a Breece owner and have no belief I could move him for any of these assets, maybe Barkley

[lukkynumber13]

I own 2 Breece shares but thankfully both of those teams I am rebuilding this year with strong aspirations to contend next year

I can’t imagine I’ll shop him, just absorb the lack of points this year and hope for the best in 2023.

[ericanadian]

Will need to get another option at RB now… going to see if the Barkley owner who is blatantly throwing his season wants to make a move.

[FantasyFreak]

They say the meniscus damage is "minor". Not suppose to impact his rehab. I suppose it could be worse.

[lukkynumber13]

The question in leagues where I’m contending… how much to pay for Michael Carter??

[Anteaters]

They say the meniscus damage is "minor". Not suppose to impact his rehab. I suppose it could be worse.

I've heard that before, pre-surgery. Then post-surgery the doctor says something like "once we were inside, we saw more damage than the imaging led us to believe."

Not saying that's definitely the case here. Just saying that if they can see "some" meniscus damage this soon, there's a good chance there's more than we'd all like.

[Mjvb5]

Hall over Chubb for me.
Players I'd swap hall for JT, swift, walker, bijan, barkley

Good luck getting this return for him. I am a Breece owner and have no belief I could move him for any of these assets, maybe Barkley

Not expecting that return but the question was who I'd give him for. He was in legit contention for rb1 prior to injury. I'm not swapping him for say Jacobs, Henry, cook or kamara

This means he's a firm hold/buy to me

[Payton34]

The question in leagues where I’m contending… how much to pay for Michael Carter??

Been wondering this as well. Especially since I have guys like Mostert and D Foreman on my bench. Bottom line with Carter is to obviously not expect similar production to Hall..

[remedy29]

The question in leagues where I’m contending… how much to pay for Michael Carter??

Been wondering this as well. Especially since I have guys like Mostert and D Foreman on my bench. Bottom line with Carter is to obviously not expect similar production to Hall..

I think there is a good chance the Jets trade for a RB, possibly Kareem Hunt. The Jets can actually have a few meaningful games later this year, but they need a good run game. M. Carter value goes up, but he will still likely split carries with someone.

[FantasyFreak]

Hall over Chubb for me.
Players I'd swap hall for JT, swift, walker, bijan, barkley

Good luck getting this return for him. I am a Breece owner and have no belief I could move him for any of these assets, maybe Barkley

Not expecting that return but the question was who I'd give him for. He was in legit contention for rb1 prior to injury. I'm not swapping him for say Jacobs, Henry, cook or kamara

This means he's a firm hold/buy to me

I mean Jacobs is only 24 and is the RB2. I'd swap Henry or Kamara for him, probably Cook, but Jacobs, being at least a few years younger than those guys, I am not moving him for Breece, not on a contender.

[MacDaddy123]

Will need to get another option at RB now… going to see if the Barkley owner who is blatantly throwing his season wants to make a move.

I also am in 1st place in the only league where I own Breece.
I suppose that I will have to start looking around.

[TimeWillTell]

Would you guys pay a 2023 1st likely in the 1.03 to 1.05 range to stash him (thinking it'll be 1.05 but too early to tell)? Looked really good but his knee is reported to be ACL and meniscus which means likely longer recovery