Should I Make This Trade

[SVF96]

I give: Tyreek, Edmonds, 24 3rd

I get: Pittman, Montgomery, 24 2nd

[Gator Sens]

I don't like either RB but I think the value is with Pittman +.

[SVF96]

I don't like either RB but I think the value is with Pittman +.

I appreciate the feedback. That’s how I am leaning now but it’s hard to stomach moving Tyreek while wanting to go for a championship.

[stevothepirate]

Pittman may be better than Tyreek this year... I would take that side in a heartbeat.

[tsarpepe]

Not ready to put Pittman above a phenom like Hill, but the addition of Monty tips the scales to that side.

[Cowboysfan33]

I like Montgomery way more than Edmonds(I don’t value him very highly) and Hill & Pittman are close enough plus you get the pick upgrade. I would definitely do this deal.

[Trevormortis]

Tough to say how things will go this year between Pittman and Hill. In a year or two it will clearly be Pittman, then add everything else on top and I'd have to take the Pittman side.

[SVF96]

Tough to say how things will go this year between Pittman and Hill. In a year or two it will clearly be Pittman, then add everything else on top and I'd have to take the Pittman side.

Would trading Tyreek take me out of contending this year in your opinion? The team I am trading him to had Jefferson, deebo, JT, CMC. Thanks!

[davieglove34]

Draft picks are 2 years away, so hard to gauge their value now, but both RBs are meh. Basically boils down to trading for a 24 yr-old WR with a very high-upside and who's yet to enter his prime vs a 28 yr-old WR who's in his prime, but has a lot of uncertainty being on a new team, and likely only has another 2-3 years for top production. Pittman side IMO

[BigBawseRoss]

pittman and montgomery and the 2nd for me. montgomery is worth a ton more than edmunds and should not be lumped in as meh with him, monty may not be sexy but hes a proven producer

[BucBuc]

Pittman Monty side slam dunk

[noen10]

I am asking for a first back in this IMO. Tyreek has more name value than pittman to me.

[SVF96]

Thanks for all the comments! The final offer I accepted was:

Pittman, Montgomery, 23 2nd and 24 2nd
For
Tyreek, Edmonds, 23 4th, 24 3rd and 4th

I then flipped my own 24 2nd and the 2 acquired 2nds for a projected late 23 1st. All in all thanks for the advise it helped me pull off this deal!

[BigBawseRoss]

Thanks for all the comments! The final offer I accepted was:

Pittman, Montgomery, 23 2nd and 24 2nd
For
Tyreek, Edmonds, 23 4th, 24 3rd and 4th

I then flipped my own 24 2nd and the 2 acquired 2nds for a projected late 23 1st. All in all thanks for the advise it helped me pull off this deal!

might regret moving 3 2nds for a 1st otherwise i dig it.

[IR1]

I like Montgomery way more than Edmonds(I don’t value him very highly) and Hill & Pittman are close enough plus you get the pick upgrade. I would definitely do this deal.

X2