Got a trade offer. Thoughts?

[TurkMatt]

Looking to move Chubb but would you consider this fair value or should I hold?

Team 3 in sig

[Gator Sens]

With the 2nd and Aiyuk being involved, this is an easy pass and hold for me. You are giving up way too much here.

[never_punts]

Not close. Your side is giving up too much

[Jigga94]

I wouldn't give up Chubb by himself for the other side.

[TurkMatt]

With the 2nd and Aiyuk being involved, this is an easy pass and hold for me. You are giving up way too much here.

Is it that the whole offer is bad return value or would you find it acceptable if say the 2nd or a diff piece was removed?

[TurkMatt]

I wouldn't give up Chubb by himself for the other side.

What is Chubb’s value in picks in your opinion?

[TurkMatt]

Not close. Your side is giving up too much

What would be needed to be added or removed in your opinion to make it bit more fair?

[Gator Sens]

With the 2nd and Aiyuk being involved, this is an easy pass and hold for me. You are giving up way too much here.

Is it that the whole offer is bad return value or would you find it acceptable if say the 2nd or a diff piece was removed?

I don't think the return in general is great but having to add Aiyuk and the 2nd on top makes the return not even close for me.

[TurkMatt]

With the 2nd and Aiyuk being involved, this is an easy pass and hold for me. You are giving up way too much here.

Is it that the whole offer is bad return value or would you find it acceptable if say the 2nd or a diff piece was removed?

I don't think the return in general is great but having to add Aiyuk and the 2nd on top makes the return not even close for me.

Ok I see. Thanks for the tip. I wasn’t sure what chubbs value is at these days and I wanted to get some more 2023 1sts but maybe it’s best I hold until the szn

[Dan49erFaithful]

This return would be more on par if you were giving up Chubb and maybe the 2nd or a 3rd. But adding Aiyuk in just throws the whole thing off. Gap between Aiyuk and Cooks is big. Same with Chubb and Harris

[BigBawseRoss]

im curious what was appealing about this

[repkllrs]

Pull out Aiyuk (who I would still trade in another deal)and it’s fine.

[TurkMatt]

im curious what was appealing about this

Just took over this team this summer and not the biggest Chubb guy so I want to get some more picks for next yr’s draft. Harris intrigued me I like his TD upside and think he can carry a bigger workload but maybe I’m being too hopeful w Belichick and his RB carousel. I get Aiyuk is younger too but think Cooks is a better weekly play. Just was the first offer I’ve gotten for Chubb also so gauging the community since I never owned him or tried to acquire him in any of my other leagues

[Jigga94]

im curious what was appealing about this

Just took over this team this summer

Makes sense. I'd be weary if someone else's Chubb fell into my lap too

[bennythedog93]

Chubb > Harris
Aiyuk > Cook
1st > 2nd

This is a hard no x2!