(SF) Barkley/Penny/Carson for 1.03/Dillon

[atlmoneyman]

I have been offered the following deal:

I get:
Rookie pick 1.03
AJ Dillon

I give:
Saquon Barkley
Raashad Penny
Chris Carson

I am contending...one of 3 teams ahead of the crowd. Since we only have to start one RB each week I am considering this. The teams at 1.01 and 1.02 both could use a QB so it wouldn't surprise me if one takes one ahead of the 1.03 pick.

12 team Superflex 1.5 TE Premium
We start 12... 1 QB, 1RB, 1WR, 1TE, 1DEF, 1 Superflex, 6 Flex

My team currently has these pieces...

QB: Pat Mahomes, Trevor Lawrence, Justin Fields
RB: Jonathan Taylor, Saquon Barkley, Rashaad Penny, Miles Sanders, Chris Carson
WR: Ja'Marr Chase, Justin Jefferson, Michael Pittman, Jerry Jeudy, Adam Thielen, Mecole Hardman, Jalen Reagor, Laviska Shenault
TE: Kyle Pitts, Irv Smith Jr., David Njoku, Ty Conklin
DEF: Browns, Lions, Panthers

Would you accept the trade offer?

[Needalife]

I'll take that deal. I love Barkley but I might roll the dice here. Penny and Carson really drag down the other side while Dillon adds a little to what you're getting.

Great team you've built.

[Gator Sens]

I am low on Dillon but would still consider this deal. I think you could flip Dillon for a solid return to the right manager and I would be looking to get out on Barkley if I had him. His value could go up if he is traded but that is a big if and his value is very fragile. Its all about which way you want to gamble here.

[atlmoneyman]

Thanks for confirming the direction I was already leaning, fellas. I accepted the deal. Honestly, glad to be out of the Saquon Barkley business at a reasonable price.

[BucBuc]

I would’ve held here mainly cause I think Dillon is over valued

[Tripwired]

I don't love it, but I myself just sold Saquon in order to get out under from him in the fear that he may never be the same. When he's actually played full games in the past two seasons, he has underwhelmed. Therfore, I'd probably take it. I'd say it's similar in value to what I got a few weeks ago.

[Mtt33]

I actually like Dillon but still an easy pass for me. Give me barkley very easily over the 1.03.

[Dynasty_Analyst]

I almost typed that it was Barkley side by a wide margin but it’s fairly close I think in the future Dillon about equals penny Carson for me but I’m low on Dillon. Barkley 1.03 is fairly close for me to, most people would probably take Barkley but I’d have to really think about it and would probably depend on team build

[JoeJoe88]

I didn’t realize so many people were so low on Dillon. Maybe I need to send out some offers…

[The.Big.Spank]

I wonder what Barkley's value would be if they traded him to the Rams for Akers.

[oneson9192]

Goodness what a team. QB1, WR1, WR2, RB1, TE1, with exciting young talent behind.

I don't have a strong opinion on the deal but wanted to say "well done"

[jtk1234]

Yikes, definitely wouldn't have done that deal. Depends on how much you like the draft class this year, but the 1.03 is definitely not worth as much this year as in previous years because the talent gap is not as wide, likely getting either Hall or Pead and you dont even know where they will end up at this point. You definitely gave away by far the most valuable trade chip in Barkley. If Barkley returns to form you have a championship team for 3-4 years easily. Would've personally asked for more or stuck it out, talent and opportunity are there if he stays healthy, but I can understand the reasoning behind wanting to move on.