Rank the 3 2019 RBs

[Razzy22]

0.5 PPR

Where are we ranking the RB class from 2019? The top guys I can see from the class are:

Josh Jacobs
Miles Sanders
David Montgomery

Have opinions changed from last year to this year? Are other RBs to be included that you rank higher?

[Gator Sens]

Jacobs
Montgomery
Sanders

I'm not sold on Sanders as a work horse and Montgomery is really coming on. Those two are a bit interchangeable though. Sanders has more value based on name alone though.

[abloom]

Jacobs
Montgomery
Sanders

I'm not sold on Sanders as a work horse and Montgomery is really coming on. Those two are a bit interchangeable though. Sanders has more value based on name alone though.

This, except I think Monty benefitted from 2 things: 1) Not having Cohen there, and 2) having a relatively easy (RB) schedule to end the season.

I have Monty in one league and I'm going to be looking to shop him this off season, especially if he continues to put up numbers in the post season.

My biggest issue with Sanders is the Eagles. Their QB situation and O-line looks bad to iffy right now.

[joeday]

I have them all very close still. Dealers choice.

[StripesOfKC]

Jacobs
Montgomery
Sanders

I'm not sold on Sanders as a work horse and Montgomery is really coming on. Those two are a bit interchangeable though. Sanders has more value based on name alone though.

x2

[cptjonesb]

Jacobs
Montgomery
Sanders

I'm not sold on Sanders as a work horse and Montgomery is really coming on. Those two are a bit interchangeable though. Sanders has more value based on name alone though.

x2

x3

[timeEd32]

1a) Sanders
1b) Jacobs
3) Monty

I think Sanders has the most risk this offseason, but I also think he has the highest upside. I think all three of them are below my top 4 from 2020 (Swift, JT, Dobbins, and Akers).

[MyTeam]

Jacobs is the #1 and Monty and Sanders are pretty close. I'd give Sanders the edge slightly.

[JJRules]

I have these guys all pretty close, each with their own question marks.

Montgomery - Were his late-season performances a sign of things to come, or strictly due to a favorable schedule?
Sanders - Can he stay healthy? Will PHI get their bleep together as a team?
Jacobs - Exciting ceiling, bottom-dwelling floor. Weekly output varies too much. Feels like a poor-man's Mixon.

Listed in order of my rankings, but the margins are small.

[OhSnapItsAnt]

Jacobs
Montgomery
Sanders

I'm not sold on Sanders as a work horse and Montgomery is really coming on. Those two are a bit interchangeable though. Sanders has more value based on name alone though.

This for me!

[CGW]

They are all very close for me.

Our draft they went
Jacobs
Monty(me)
Sanders

Today i would probably have it the same and could be swayed any direction depending on what happens this off season. Jacob's has the most stable situation. Monty will likely see a new coaching staff, qb, and the return of cohen. Sanders is stuck on a team in serious cap hell.

[M-Dub]

Same as I’ve had it since at least March of 2019:

Sanders
Jacobs
Montgomery

Sanders is the only one who has true elite upside, IMO. I see Jacobs and Monty capped as back-end RB1s.

[CGW]

Same as I’ve had it since at least March of 2019:

Sanders
Jacobs
Montgomery

Sanders is the only one who has true elite upside, IMO. I see Jacobs and Monty capped as back-end RB1s.

You mean going forward right? Cause Monty just finished as RB4 in PPR and I consider that mid to top end RB1...but I tend to agree his upside isn't quite as high as what sanders could be.

[joeday]

Same as I’ve had it since at least March of 2019:

Sanders
Jacobs
Montgomery

Sanders is the only one who has true elite upside, IMO. I see Jacobs and Monty capped as back-end RB1s.

You mean going forward right? Cause Monty just finished as RB4 in PPR and I consider that mid to top end RB1...but I tend to agree his upside isn't quite as high as what sanders could be.

I really like Monty, I was in on him as a rookie and got him anywhere I could...that said, I have never seen an easier schedule for an RB the last 6 weeks of the season. Believe me, I loved it and rode the wave but I don't think either of the other two RBs woulda done worse in those matchups.

[M-Dub]

Same as I’ve had it since at least March of 2019:

Sanders
Jacobs
Montgomery

Sanders is the only one who has true elite upside, IMO. I see Jacobs and Monty capped as back-end RB1s.

You mean going forward right? Cause Monty just finished as RB4 in PPR and I consider that mid to top end RB1...but I tend to agree his upside isn't quite as high as what sanders could be.

Touché. I’ll own that one. I hadn’t checked the top performers in a bit. I knew Monty had been killing it down the stretch, but didn’t realize it was enough to vault him into the top 5. Still, he strikes me as an average back who fell into a perfect situation this season. I’d be trying my damnedest to sell high if I owned him anywhere. (I don’t, obviously. Haha.)