Golladay offer

[makemeasandwich]

Not unless you are very high on Golladay. I am an owner and like him, but I don't think he is going to be a top 5 WR option moving forward (which that price tag suggests). Is the owner super high on Golladay? I think the best option is to take CEH and JT at 1.1 and 1.2 and offer gallup and 1.6 for golladay. You would still have good options at WR and could have 4 great options to choose from at RB each week. Or trade one of the rookies for a WR haul 6 weeks in when one of them is really flashing.

I agree with this. take the top 2 RBs and see if you can trade 1.06+ for Golladay. Or as stated above, inquire on A-Rob by using the 1.02.

You'd use the 1.2 to get A-Rob over Golladay? I thought the majority of the community would put Golladay over ARob? I don't mean this in a negative way, just a question.

A-Rob outscored Golladay depending on the format and did so with a much more reasonable TD number at 7 opposed to 11. A-rob is going to push for a 25% target share once again, he's a locked WR1.

[makemeasandwich]

I don't think Golladay is going to be a top 12 WR next year, Keep the 1.02 and grab one of these rookie RB's.

Man was top 12 with half a season of Driskel and Blough and WR6 with Stafford and continues to be doubted

Pretty much a guarantee he will be top 12

Meanwhile people are still out there hyping up bums like Juju

But for this I'd lean to the 1.2 side. Close though

His TD rate is unsustainable, if he scored a more reasonable 7 TD's he wouldn't have been in the top 12. He will have to see more volume with Stafford to push into the top 12 without a league high 11 TD's.

[imi814]

Gallup and Golladay are not that far off.

I agree Gallup is undervalued but so is Golladay. They are fairly far off

Gallup is a very late 1st between around 1.10. Golladay is between 1.2 and 1.3 IMO

I don’t think Gallup is worth a late first right now. He is behind cooper and lamb. How many points will the number 3 option be able to get?

[StripesOfKC]

Gallup and Golladay are not that far off.

I agree Gallup is undervalued but so is Golladay. They are fairly far off

Gallup is a very late 1st between around 1.10. Golladay is between 1.2 and 1.3 IMO

I don’t think Gallup is worth a late first right now. He is behind cooper and lamb. How many points will the number 3 option be able to get?

He won't be behind Lamb in 2020 IMO and he is a FA after 2021 when Cooper has an out

Only 2021 is when I think he will not be a top 2 WR

Dallas also has 190 vacated targets--more than enough for Lamb to have a decent rookie year, Jarwin to replace Witten and for Gallup to keep his 113 targets or even improve on that total

[AresGodOWar3]

I would take the GDay side I like him over the 1.02 and the 1.08 over the rest

[jjleurquin]

Gallup is better than current value. I'd hold him here. He was getting more targets per game than Cooper was. I think Gallup and a 2nd is about even value. You're giving up way too much here.

[dblj1199]

Not unless you are very high on Golladay. I am an owner and like him, but I don't think he is going to be a top 5 WR option moving forward (which that price tag suggests). Is the owner super high on Golladay? I think the best option is to take CEH and JT at 1.1 and 1.2 and offer gallup and 1.6 for golladay. You would still have good options at WR and could have 4 great options to choose from at RB each week. Or trade one of the rookies for a WR haul 6 weeks in when one of them is really flashing.

Ditto

[Edgy68]

I’d start with 1.06 and Gallup to feel out the other owner. The 1.02 for Golladay might be enough as well. No need to give up so much unless you can’t keep them all anyway. I like the idea of checking with the ARob owner if this falls through.

[EAGLES]

1.2 should be right around Golladay’s value. I also think I’d prefer the 1.8 (Jeudy, Jefferson or Raegor) over Gallup and 2.06. However, as others have already said I’d try sending the 1.06 for Golladay to gauge the other owners value on him and try keeping the 1.02.