DJM/Mixon Trade (Poll)

[Hankybro21]

Team 1.

Mixon owner is in rebuild and asked on DJM. I love DJM and have no problem holding him in the case of injury or when my WR's start to age a bit, but I am quite light at RB. My initial thought is to ask for more on top of Mixon and not do this straight up, and/or simply wait to see how the draft board falls and if I can get RB help there (as of now, I have picks 8, 10, and 11 overall). Mixon was obviously solid last year, but with the disaster that Cincy has been this year, I simply have no idea how to value him now or going forward a year or two.

Is this something to consider straight up? Ask for a little on top? Or simply hold for a better RB trade return? Thanks all, as always.

His team is as follows:
QB: Rodgers, Brissett, Cam
RB: Singletary, Mixon, Kareem, KJ, McKissic, Scarbrough, Darwin
WR: Gallup, McLaurin, Dede, Josh Gordon, MVS, N'Keal, Parris, Isabella, Hardman, Renfrow
TE: Griffin, Njoku, Gesicki
Picks as of now: 1.01, 1.04, 1.06, 2.10

[lukkynumber13]

I love Mixon. But you need at least an early 2nd, probably a First, on top of Mixon to sell Moore.

[Gator Sens]

I love Mixon. But you need at least an early 2nd, probably a First, on top of Mixon to sell Moore.

x2 - seems fair.

[hoos89]

I don't think I'd sell Moore right now...I expect his value to increase significantly this offseason once his full season numbers sink in. He's having a nearly JuJu-like second season in spite of a much worse situation than JuJu had last season.

I'd want more than a late first on top of Mixon.

[Hankybro21]

Yea okay, seems like what I was thinking. I could ask for the 1.06 or 1.04 on top but even then I’d have a tough time

[hoos89]

Yea okay, seems like what I was thinking. I could ask for the 1.06 or 1.04 on top but even then I’d have a tough time

I'd still pretty easily do Mixon + 1.04-1.06 for Moore given that 1.04-1.06 is likely to be one of Lamb, Etienne, or Dobbins.

[Dibbles]

Yea okay, seems like what I was thinking. I could ask for the 1.06 or 1.04 on top but even then I’d have a tough time

I'd still pretty easily do Mixon + 1.04-1.06 for Moore given that 1.04-1.06 is likely to be one of Lamb, Etienne, or Dobbins.

^ This, and I love DJM.

[Hankybro21]

Yea okay, seems like what I was thinking. I could ask for the 1.06 or 1.04 on top but even then I’d have a tough time

I'd still pretty easily do Mixon + 1.04-1.06 for Moore given that 1.04-1.06 is likely to be one of Lamb, Etienne, or Dobbins.

^ This, and I love DJM.

Fair enough. I told him I’d consider with the 1.04 so let’s see what he says

[BigBawseRoss]

man i dont own any dj moore but there isnt a league or setup where i can imagine myself adding even an early 2nd to mixon to get moore.

[BigBawseRoss]

Yea okay, seems like what I was thinking. I could ask for the 1.06 or 1.04 on top but even then I’d have a tough time

you shouldnt, you would be getting back a player at a harder to fill position who has similar dynasty value AND a top 6 pick in a supposedly loaded class aka another possible stud player.

[hoos89]

man i dont own any dj moore but there isnt a league or setup where i can imagine myself adding even an early 2nd to mixon to get moore.

Moore is pacing for 99 receptions, 1,364 yards from scrimmage and 4 TDs at 22 with a backup QB while Mixon is struggling. Not sure how you could turn down Mixon + 2nd for Moore at this point.

Yea okay, seems like what I was thinking. I could ask for the 1.06 or 1.04 on top but even then I’d have a tough time

you shouldnt, you would be getting back a player at a harder to fill position who has similar dynasty value AND a top 6 pick in a supposedly loaded class aka another possible stud player.

I don't think Mixon and Moore have similar dynasty value anymore. I don't think we'll really see that reflected in rankings/ADP until the offseason, but if Moore and Mixon finish near their current paces, I expect Moore will be a top 15 startup pick and Mixon will be in the 30-40 range.

[XclickX]

I’d take Moore over Mixon straight up. DJM WR 10 rn in full ppr( he’ll be 11th after Kupp plays tonight). Still 11th = WR1 with Kyle Allen at qb and at age 22! Give me 7-8( maybe more) studly years of DJM over 4 more years of Mixon as a nfl starting rb.

[Hankybro21]

Thanks all. He wouldn’t do anything but mixon straight up for DJM so no deal to be had