Chubb trade, which side

[Hankybro21]

Team 2

Give: Mixon + Jacobs

Get: Chubb

I like Jacobs and mixon but getting Chubb would be a big get I think. Thoughts?

[Gator Sens]

I think long term, this is the Mixon side. You could have 2 RB1's vs 1 with Chubb. That's only if you think Mixon rebounds.

[Hankybro21]

I hear you on that, good point.

FWIW, lll be drafting swift and Taylor most likely as well. So could have swift taylor and Chubb or swift Taylor mixon and Jacobs

[Gator Sens]

I hear you on that, good point.

FWIW, lll be drafting swift and Taylor most likely as well. So could have swift taylor and Chubb or swift Taylor mixon and Jacobs

That makes me lean Chubb but there is no guarantee those guys pan out.

[Slackalacker]

I prefer the Mixon side. Coming into the season Mixon was worth more, I think the talents there and he’s still quite young. The gap between the two is not Jacobs, even with how Mixon has played.

[Hankybro21]

I prefer the Mixon side. Coming into the season Mixon was worth more, I think the talents there and he’s still quite young. The gap between the two is not Jacobs, even with how Mixon has played.

That’s fair. I might just be getting impatient with mixon but holding is prolly the right move

[Samhain34]

Everybody is talking about Mixon, but I wouldn't give up Jacobs. I'm hanging onto Jacobs and dumping Mixon if I can get a decent deal for him. I'd be looking to dump Mixon and a draft pick or two and go hunting for a legit WR1 on a rebuilding team or, if you're set at trading up for a RB, I'm looking for Zeke or Saquon.

[chubnubbin]

mixon side

[BigBawseRoss]

jacobs and mixon

[Goddard]

I don't get how there are so many votes for Chubb. The gap between Chubb and Mixon isn't Jacobs, and the gap between Chubb and Jacobs isn't Mixon.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

If you were looking for a win-now piece to put you over the top, I'd consider a slight overpay for Chubb. However, since you're not in contention, I'd rather hold Jacobs + Mixon.

Also, I think there's an argument that Jacobs > Mixon at this point, so if the Chubb owner is rebuilding as well, maybe Mixon + 2020 1st for Chubb + 2020 2nd might get it done?