Rookie Draft: Trade Up Value?

[sperl14]

Hi All -

Rookie draft this evening. This is a Superflex. .5 PPR. Have the #5 pick but am in talks to move up to 3.

Team in 3 slot has asked for this year's 2nd round rookie pick plus a 2020 second-round rookie in order for me to move up. Thoughts on value/counter offer? If I stay at 5, i would hope that Montgomery or Sanders is still there - but really tempting to secure Harry (or someone else if they fall) for the next decade.

Appreciate any insights.

Thanks!
Garrett

[sperl14]

To clarify. Proposed comp is:

Give Up:
Swap 2019 2nd round picks (I move down two slots)
2020 2nd

Receive: Move up from 5 to 3 in 2019 Rookie Draft.

[moishetreats]

If you have a top-3 that you like, then this isn't expensive to move up and lock him it. Go for it.

But...

If I stay at 5, i would hope that Montgomery or Sanders is still there - but really tempting to secure Harry (or someone else if they fall) for the next decade.

...your math is off. Murray, Jacobs, Harry, Montgomery, Sanders: that's five. If you're trading up because you like Harry better but because you don't want to risk none of Harry, Montgomery, or Sanders falling, then that means that either Jacobs or Murray (!!) somehow fell.

It seems like you have a tier of 5, so I'd stay put. If you really want Harry, then I'd also wait until 1.03 is on the clock: he could go 1.02.

[Ogallagher13]

In superflex there is a tier of 5 in my opinion so there is no reason to move up in my opinion. If you value one guy a lot more than the others it seems ok.