Michael Thomas Trade & Value?

[bkfakefootball]

Give: DJ Moore & N’Keal Harry

Get: Michael Thomas

Just wondering what people think of this and am I giving away enough value in 2 possible future top 10 WR’s. I think the value is fair now just wanted to see what some thoughts are on this one long term? Thanks everyone!

[Gator Sens]

This is easily Thomas. Short and long term. Thomas is a proven stud, top 3 WR in football. Moore and Harry both have big hype and are very intriguing prospects, but Thomas is in a totally different tier. Nice deal for you!

[srlarson]

as a Thomas owner no way that is enough.....if it's being offered take it and run.....if putting together will need to step up

[FantasyFoosball]

If this was offered you should have snap accepted it. If you are thinking of offering it, you are nowhere close. And I own MT and DJ Moore.

[Bubba90]

Take MT and run!!!!! Don’t walk, run!!!!!

[Mike from Canada]

Did you offer this for Thomas? Insulting.

[FuzzySignificance]

this one, I'd do for Thomas, depending on where my team was at.

[bkfakefootball]

Did you offer this for Thomas? Insulting.

I guess you insult easily. If it were seasonal I’d say insulting but Dynasty is about projected long term value and it’s all subjective so they are both potentially WR1’s so seems like a fair offer to me but again every opinion is different

[#1BucsFan]

Why are people so bent over on saying this is such an unfair trade, it's much closer than people are making it out to be. I would take the Thomas side, but the value is close enough where I wouldn't fault anyone who is rebuilding and taking the package.

[jetsfan5757]

I REALLY doubt that gets it done for Thomas. Not saying it's insulting, but I think it's low.

[ChefHerbie]

Why are people so bent over on saying this is such an unfair trade, it's much closer than people are making it out to be. I would take the Thomas side, but the value is close enough where I wouldn't fault anyone who is rebuilding and taking the package.

Lol no it's not, it's Thomas by an absolute landslide. DJ Moore has played one season (55-788-2) and N'Keal Harry has never played a snap at the NFL level. Meanwhile Thomas has been in the league three years, and has worst season in terms of fantasy pts was 112-1,245-5, thats over 100pts better than Moore. All three seasons he's been in the league, MT has posted a season over 100 fantasy pts better than what Moore did as a rookie. Heck, the 310.5pt season Thomas just put up last year is double the points DJ put up. Yeah, yeah, spare me the DJ didn't start six games, here is his extrapolated scoreline: 67-864-2 (165.4 pts), still just a cool 145pts behind MT.

[ChefHerbie]

Did you offer this for Thomas? Insulting.

I guess you insult easily. If it were seasonal I’d say insulting but Dynasty is about projected long term value and it’s all subjective so they are both potentially WR1’s so seems like a fair offer to me but again every opinion is different

Would you sell one of Barkley/CMC/Kamara for any of these combo's Chubb/Sanders, Chubb/Monty, Chubb/Jacobs? I know I sure wouldn't, but it's two potential RB1's....

Not saying it's insulting, but your asking for a proven Elite Top 3-5 WR1 for two guys that are hyped to be WR1's but no one really knows, and one hasn't even played a snap yet. As an unbiased third party your offer isn't fair. You're right, and everyone has their own opinion, but I'd bet you that 90%+ of people would say it's not a fair offer.

[bkfakefootball]

Did you offer this for Thomas? Insulting.

I guess you insult easily. If it were seasonal I’d say insulting but Dynasty is about projected long term value and it’s all subjective so they are both potentially WR1’s so seems like a fair offer to me but again every opinion is different

Would you sell one of Barkley/CMC/Kamara for any of these combo's Chubb/Sanders, Chubb/Monty, Chubb/Jacobs? I know I sure wouldn't, but it's two potential RB1's....

Not saying it's insulting, but your asking for a proven Elite Top 3-5 WR1 for two guys that are hyped to be WR1's but no one really knows, and one hasn't even played a snap yet. As an unbiased third party your offer isn't fair. You're right, and everyone has their own opinion, but I'd bet you that 90%+ of people would say it's not a fair offer.

I can appreciate that opinion for sure, which is why posting and getting feedback from this site is great. Maybe they counter or except and go from there but there is a lot of hype around all these players and with Brees playing for who knows how long and the Saints running the ball more Thomas might not put up monster numbers like in the past so every player has risks. They all 3 have pretty high draft capital and I think that can be telling for projected value.

[ChefHerbie]

I guess you insult easily. If it were seasonal I’d say insulting but Dynasty is about projected long term value and it’s all subjective so they are both potentially WR1’s so seems like a fair offer to me but again every opinion is different

Would you sell one of Barkley/CMC/Kamara for any of these combo's Chubb/Sanders, Chubb/Monty, Chubb/Jacobs? I know I sure wouldn't, but it's two potential RB1's....

Not saying it's insulting, but your asking for a proven Elite Top 3-5 WR1 for two guys that are hyped to be WR1's but no one really knows, and one hasn't even played a snap yet. As an unbiased third party your offer isn't fair. You're right, and everyone has their own opinion, but I'd bet you that 90%+ of people would say it's not a fair offer.

I can appreciate that opinion for sure, which is why posting and getting feedback from this site is great. Maybe they counter or except and go from there but there is a lot of hype around all these players and with Brees playing for who knows how long and the Saints running the ball more Thomas might not put up monster numbers like in the past so every player has risks. They all 3 have pretty high draft capital and I think that can be telling for projected value.

The Saints ran the ball more in '18 than '17, and Thomas put up better numbers than ever. You could also say the same about Brady potentially retiring soon, and point to the severe injuries Cam has suffered. Point being literally any player could have some negatives spun their way, but when looking at what we know, I just don't think there's any way to pitch it as a reasonable offer. That said, I do wish you the best of luck and hopefully he accepts it and you have an absolute steal.

[bkfakefootball]

Would you sell one of Barkley/CMC/Kamara for any of these combo's Chubb/Sanders, Chubb/Monty, Chubb/Jacobs? I know I sure wouldn't, but it's two potential RB1's....

Not saying it's insulting, but your asking for a proven Elite Top 3-5 WR1 for two guys that are hyped to be WR1's but no one really knows, and one hasn't even played a snap yet. As an unbiased third party your offer isn't fair. You're right, and everyone has their own opinion, but I'd bet you that 90%+ of people would say it's not a fair offer.

I can appreciate that opinion for sure, which is why posting and getting feedback from this site is great. Maybe they counter or except and go from there but there is a lot of hype around all these players and with Brees playing for who knows how long and the Saints running the ball more Thomas might not put up monster numbers like in the past so every player has risks. They all 3 have pretty high draft capital and I think that can be telling for projected value.

The Saints ran the ball more in '18 than '17, and Thomas put up better numbers than ever. You could also say the same about Brady potentially retiring soon, and point to the severe injuries Cam has suffered. Point being literally any player could have some negatives spun their way, but when looking at what we know, I just don't think there's any way to pitch it as a reasonable offer. That said, I do wish you the best of luck and hopefully he accepts it and you have an absolute steal.

Thanks, I appreciate the reply!