Mixon/Lindsay+

[SWIMball]

I have the opportunity to trade Mixon for Lindsay, DJ Moore, and a 2020 1st from one of the weakest teams in the league. Should I go for it?

[Gator Sens]

Pretty solid value on paper but I would hold Mixon. I would not fault anyone for taking this deal though.

[BucFanJKE]

^^

[hoos89]

Given that the 2020 1st is from a bad team, I think that's a pretty good value.

[kmbryant09]

I would take that deal pretty easily, but I'm a believer in Lindsay.

[alphaxray]

I would sell Mixon for that.

[Finfansteve]

I’d keep Mixon. We don’t know how Lindsay’s gonna be used this year by the new coaching staff and with the dominant talent Mixon is I’d just keep him and his lack of competition for touches whereas Lindsay has freeman to deal with

[ChefHerbie]

I'd hold Mixon

[CrimeLord]

I'd trade Mixon for that. Lindsay still fills your RB spot. Potential star with DJ and early 2020 1st can likely yield a high end RB. Great value.

[lukkynumber13]

Pretty solid value on paper but I would hold Mixon. I would not fault anyone for taking this deal though.

Yup, Very well said.

[Finfansteve]

I get the feeling that a year from now we’ll be wondering how we even considered trading Mixon for Lindsay and a pick.

[M-Dub]

I get the feeling that a year from now we’ll be wondering how we even considered trading Mixon for Lindsay and a pick.

To be fair, there’s a pretty damn nice WR prospect in the package too.

As someone who owns (and likes) both Mixon and Lindsay, I’m torn on this deal. I guess that means I think it’s pretty fair. It probably comes down to what most of these even trades come down to. If I was rebuilding and in need of multiple young upside pieces, I’d probably take Lindsay, Moore and the early 1st. If I’m competing, I’d probably just hold Mixon.

[hoos89]

I get the feeling that a year from now we’ll be wondering how we even considered trading Mixon for Lindsay and a pick.

DJ Moore is also in the deal? Also that pick is a 2020 1st that projects early. Early 2020 1sts are likely to be worth a ton at this time next year. Lindsay is the least valuable piece in the package.

[Finfansteve]

I get the feeling that a year from now we’ll be wondering how we even considered trading Mixon for Lindsay and a pick.

To be fair, there’s a pretty damn nice WR prospect in the package too.

As someone who owns (and likes) both Mixon and Lindsay, I’m torn on this deal. I guess that means I think it’s pretty fair. It probably comes down to what most of these even trades come down to. If I was rebuilding and in need of multiple young upside pieces, I’d probably take Lindsay, Moore and the early 1st. If I’m competing, I’d probably just hold Mixon.

Oh shoot. I missed the dj Moore inclusion part of this trade. With him included it comes down more to personal preference on your part. It’s slot more even now but I think I’d still keep mixon

[SteveMaddensShoes]

I'd probably sell Mixon for that. I like Moore and the 2020 1st is going to be worth enough to go for it.

If you can sell Lindsay after the trade though I'd do that