Mack or 1.02 ***UPDATE***

[crip7300]

Trade is for team 4 in sig. I'm pretty torn on this, I like Mack and obviously his situation but both Harry and Sanders are super intriguing to me.

***UPDATE***
First off thanks for all the advice and opinions, I think I'm leaning towards keeping Mack and told the owner that but now he is offering the 1.02 and 1.10 for Mack and Kirk. I'm not sure if i like Kirk or the 1.10 more, which will more than likely wind up being either AJ Brown or Fant for me. Here is another issue that I forgot to mention, I own this owners 2020 1st round pick, so giving him the more proven players could hurt my draft position next year. Still so torn on what to do, because i think for the long run I like the talents of Harry or Sanders more than Mack and I think I like AJ Brown and Fant more than Kirk (even though his situation is 10x better), What would you do?

Also crazy that with 60 votes in that it is dead even at 30 votes each.

[Gronk]

I think if I'm buying Mack I won't pay the 1.02 but if I'm selling I'll take the 1.02 for Mack. I guess with your team the question is who do you prefer in your flex? Mack or whoever you pick @1.02? Mack will likely outscore Harry for at least this year.

[ChefHerbie]

Mack for me, not close.

[Dynasty DeLorean]

I would rather have Harry. But I don’t really see the point in trading Mack for sanders. If that’s your endgame just keep mack

[FantasyFreak]

I would rather have Harry. But I don’t really see the point in trading Mack for sanders. If that’s your endgame just keep mack

Yep.

[Gator Sens]

I would rather have Harry. But I don’t really see the point in trading Mack for sanders. If that’s your endgame just keep mack

x3

[lukkynumber13]

For dynasty purposes, it feels like bad business not to take the pick.

But if it helps you win a ship this year, I’m ok with keeping Mack.

Ideally, I’d take the 1.02, then trade down to the mid First and get a 2nd on top

[cougarplayer20]

As much as I like Harry I don’t like taking WRs in rookie drafts because they are so easy to acquire later on. And I heard somewhere that we are hoping Sanders becomes Mack and that kinda makes since. So for those reasons I would take Mack here.

[Fantasy>>>Reality]

Mack for me

[Cowboysfan33]

That’s a very nice roster and with Mack, I think that team should contend for the championship. You are stronger at RB so you could afford to do it, but I would just keep Mack and go for the championship.

[Bucky15]

That’s a very nice roster and with Mack, I think that team should contend for the championship. You are stronger at RB so you could afford to do it, but I would just keep Mack and go for the championship.

x2 I think the 1.02 is a solid offer for Mack, but you definitely look like a contender. So strictly for this year I think your team is better with Mack than the 1.02. Keep him and go for the ship!

[killer_of_giants]

And I heard somewhere that we are hoping Sanders becomes Mack and that kinda makes since.

i think sanders has the numbers to be better than mack (but probably not this season).
i really struggle to see what many people see in mack though...

[Dizzle]

I think if I'm buying Mack I won't pay the 1.02 but if I'm selling I'll take the 1.02 for Mack. I guess with your team the question is who do you prefer in your flex? Mack or whoever you pick @1.02? Mack will likely outscore Harry for at least this year.

This

[ChefHerbie]

And I heard somewhere that we are hoping Sanders becomes Mack and that kinda makes since.

i think sanders has the numbers to be better than mack (but probably not this season).
i really struggle to see what many people see in mack though...

Averaged 4.7ypc last year, only 23, running behind a T5 OL in the league, T5 Off. in the league, Indy has said they view him as a bell cow, and teams can't afford to load the box with the Colts passing attack. Who knows how this year turns out for him, but Mack has a lot of things working in his favor that could make him a T10 back this year, after he was the #14 RB in PPR last year for avg ppg.

[psfox2010]

I'd take Mack here unless you're targeting Harry. If healthy for the season, Mack will be a RB1. He's on a top offense, with a top offensive lines. To me he's one of the most underrated RBs in the league.