Difference between K. Allen and B. Cooks

[kmbryant09]

Trying to get younger at WR while picking up multiple assets, trying to gauge the difference between my K. Allen and another owner's B. Cooks.

If I ask for his 2020 1st, would I have to throw in my 2nd? Is that even worth it? The other owner is probably a playoff team, but probably not among the top 2 - 3 in the league.

What makes up the difference between the two WRs?

[Gator Sens]

Allen's name carries more clout for some reason, but I don't see a huge difference. A 2nd on the cooks side should do it

[SteveMaddensShoes]

Narrative around Cooks is pretty negative atm. 2nd might not do it but I wouldn't want to add a 1st.

I'd try for someone like Corey Davis or Godwin and ask for a 1st on top. They are both on a career arc to match Cooks avg yearly production if they take the next step.

[Goddard]

I like Cooks, but I'd still need at least a mid/late 1st on top of him to move Allen.

[kmbryant09]

Any more thoughts?

[sloth8u]

Id check the cooks owner to see if he'd even add. Ive spent alot of time on a few teams this offseason and found i could have saved a bunch if time by simply getting a gauge of how my partners value my asset aswell as their own.

[lukkynumber13]

I like Cooks, but I'd still need at least a mid/late 1st on top of him to move Allen.

x2

Cooks is more electric, but Allen is a Larry Fitzgerald level technician. He will be murdering DBs for several more years.

[hoos89]

I personally wouldn't add to Cooks for Keenan. Unless the Cooks owner came to you, I wouldn't expect an add. Of course you should ask for one, but don't be surprised if the ask is straight up.

[Finfansteve]

Narrative around Cooks is pretty negative atm. 2nd might not do it but I wouldn't want to add a 1st.

I'd try for someone like Corey Davis or Godwin and ask for a 1st on top. They are both on a career arc to match Cooks avg yearly production if they take the next step.

I haven’t heard anything negative on cooks lately but I’ve been on vacation the last 10 days what have I missed?

[hoos89]

Narrative around Cooks is pretty negative atm. 2nd might not do it but I wouldn't want to add a 1st.

I'd try for someone like Corey Davis or Godwin and ask for a 1st on top. They are both on a career arc to match Cooks avg yearly production if they take the next step.

I haven’t heard anything negative on cooks lately but I’ve been on vacation the last 10 days what have I missed?

I don't think you missed anything. I disagree that the narrative around Cooks is negative.

[Hottoddies]

Trying to get younger at WR while picking up multiple assets, trying to gauge the difference between my K. Allen and another owner's B. Cooks.

If I ask for his 2020 1st, would I have to throw in my 2nd? Is that even worth it? The other owner is probably a playoff team, but probably not among the top 2 - 3 in the league.

What makes up the difference between the two WRs?

I ran this through the DLF dynasty trade analyzer and Allen + 2020 2nd for Cooks + 2020 1st came out really even. I think I'd rather have Cooks and a 2020 1st. FWIW, Cooks & 2020 2nd wasn't enough for Allen.

[jwb32]

Allen was WR11 while Cooks was WR15. And last year (and year before) Cooks was in a new system. I doubt any Cooks owner is adding a 1st (I certainly wouldn't). Maybe you could get a 2020 2nd.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Agree that as a Cooks owner, I would not add a 1st to him to get Allen. I'd say Allen = Cooks + early/mid 2nd.