Darrell Henderson Trade

[JasonM31]

For my team listed in my sig, I offered the Cook owner Mattison and DaeSean Hamilton for Darrell Henderson. Felt like that was a little light considering Henderson MIGHT have a role and I honestly want that Gurley insurance. He countered with Pettis and Mattison. Strongly considering it because I have a logjam of young WRs and I already own Kittle. Not expecting SF to be THAT great on offense to support multiple pieces. Thoughts?

[Gator Sens]

I guess I don't see much difference between Mattison and Henderson. Straight deal seems fair or adding a 3rd or something. Neither have seen the field. Mattison will play behind a guy that has struggles to stay on the field and Gurley may or may not be the same workhorse he has been. Hamilton seems like an overpay and based on the overall community value of Pettis, that is a huge overpay.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

I guess it depends on how you feel about Gurley. Personally, I think Pettis alone >= Henderson.

[JasonM31]

I guess it depends on how you feel about Gurley. Personally, I think Pettis alone >= Henderson.

That’s my original thought too. I feel like straight up would be fair. Thinking of countering with either Mattison and a 3rd or Pettis straight up.

[briank]

For my team listed in my sig, I offered the Cook owner Mattison and DaeSean Hamilton for Darrell Henderson. Felt like that was a little light considering Henderson MIGHT have a role and I honestly want that Gurley insurance. He countered with Pettis and Mattison. Strongly considering it because I have a logjam of young WRs and I already own Kittle. Not expecting SF to be THAT great on offense to support multiple pieces. Thoughts?

I think your original offer was fair. Honestly, Mattison might have more of an immediate role than Henderson. I'm not sure they are all that different in terms of value. His counter is unreasonable IMO.

[Goddard]

I wouldn't overpay for a handcuff.