Saquon Barkley - Dynasty Discussion Thread

[FantasyFreak]

I recently traded Barkley in a different dynasty league I'm in for Tyreek, Evans, Aaron Jones and a 2020 1st. Seems like a smash accept offer right? It took me a week to accept that offer. If you own Barkley you just dont want to trade him. He's almost the perfect dynasty player. Stud on the field, young, low risk off the field, everything. If you dont own Barkley you dont get that. The value is on the package side pretty easily but I still hesitated for way too long because it Barkley

Your trade partner clearly has no idea what he's doing.

[MattDeezy]

I recently traded Barkley in a different dynasty league I'm in for Tyreek, Evans, Aaron Jones and a 2020 1st. Seems like a smash accept offer right? It took me a week to accept that offer. If you own Barkley you just dont want to trade him. He's almost the perfect dynasty player. Stud on the field, young, low risk off the field, everything. If you dont own Barkley you dont get that. The value is on the package side pretty easily but I still hesitated for way too long because it Barkley

Yes I think thats a smash accept. I recently traded Barkley/Godwin for Evans/Chubb/2.06 (16th overall). So your return was even better than mine!

Sorry to say but I don’t think you got enough.

[Cameron Giles]

I recently traded Barkley in a different dynasty league I'm in for Tyreek, Evans, Aaron Jones and a 2020 1st. Seems like a smash accept offer right? It took me a week to accept that offer. If you own Barkley you just dont want to trade him. He's almost the perfect dynasty player. Stud on the field, young, low risk off the field, everything. If you dont own Barkley you dont get that. The value is on the package side pretty easily but I still hesitated for way too long because it Barkley

This is the type of Godfather offer you trade Barkley for. Two WR1's, a 1st and an upside RB. You could trade Hill or Evans for a RB1 if you wanted to and still be good.

[Bot101]

I recently traded Barkley in a different dynasty league I'm in for Tyreek, Evans, Aaron Jones and a 2020 1st. Seems like a smash accept offer right? It took me a week to accept that offer. If you own Barkley you just dont want to trade him. He's almost the perfect dynasty player. Stud on the field, young, low risk off the field, everything. If you dont own Barkley you dont get that. The value is on the package side pretty easily but I still hesitated for way too long because it Barkley

Yes I think thats a smash accept. I recently traded Barkley/Godwin for Evans/Chubb/2.06 (16th overall). So your return was even better than mine!

Sorry to say but I don’t think you got enough.

Eh I disagree. But we will certainly find out this coming season.

[Cult of Dionysus]

Yeah, you could take Godwin out and wouldn't accept that.

[FantasyFreak]

I recently traded Barkley in a different dynasty league I'm in for Tyreek, Evans, Aaron Jones and a 2020 1st. Seems like a smash accept offer right? It took me a week to accept that offer. If you own Barkley you just dont want to trade him. He's almost the perfect dynasty player. Stud on the field, young, low risk off the field, everything. If you dont own Barkley you dont get that. The value is on the package side pretty easily but I still hesitated for way too long because it Barkley

Yes I think thats a smash accept. I recently traded Barkley/Godwin for Evans/Chubb/2.06 (16th overall). So your return was even better than mine!

Sorry to say but I don’t think you got enough.

I think that's a good deal for both. I think Chubb will be Zeke like soon. Remember when Zeke didn't catch enough passes? Chubb already made one of the catches of the year last year. To me the difference between Chubb and Barkley is negligible to that of Evans and Godwin. It's a fair deal, but if Chubb rushes for 1300-1400 yards and catches 50 passes, this deal is a win. I definitely think with BOT101's roster and starting requirements (which I know about, but you don't), it works for him for the next 2-3 years.

[Cult of Dionysus]

Not saying Evans and Chubb and 2.06 is a terrible deal for Barkely, I just wouldn't accept it. Adding Godwin to the Barkley side tough makes it a pretty bad deal, imho, and just mho.

[FantasyFreak]

Not saying Evans and Chubb and 2.06 is a terrible deal for Barkely, I just wouldn't accept it. Adding Godwin to the Barkley side tough makes it a pretty bad deal, imho, and just mho.

Chubb will score closer to Barkley next year.

[MattDeezy]

Yes I think thats a smash accept. I recently traded Barkley/Godwin for Evans/Chubb/2.06 (16th overall). So your return was even better than mine!

Sorry to say but I don’t think you got enough.

I think that's a good deal for both. I think Chubb will be Zeke like soon. Remember when Zeke didn't catch enough passes? Chubb already made one of the catches of the year last year. To me the difference between Chubb and Barkley is negligible to that of Evans and Godwin. It's a fair deal, but if Chubb rushes for 1300-1400 yards and catches 50 passes, this deal is a win. I definitely think with BOT101's roster and starting requirements (which I know about, but you don't), it works for him for the next 2-3 years.

It’s cool to have a differing opinion but why make an assumption like that?

[Bot101]

Sorry to say but I don’t think you got enough.

I think that's a good deal for both. I think Chubb will be Zeke like soon. Remember when Zeke didn't catch enough passes? Chubb already made one of the catches of the year last year. To me the difference between Chubb and Barkley is negligible to that of Evans and Godwin. It's a fair deal, but if Chubb rushes for 1300-1400 yards and catches 50 passes, this deal is a win. I definitely think with BOT101's roster and starting requirements (which I know about, but you don't), it works for him for the next 2-3 years.

It’s cool to have a differing opinion but why make an assumption like that?

Ive PM'd him several times. I put my starting requirements in sig. Its deeper than average.

[FantasyFreak]

Barkley needs to get you a haul that improves your starting lineup for years, because he will be a difference maker for years. If you sell for short term gain, you will be kicking yourself.

[smallxl]

I know Barkley is the #1 dynasty asset. What do we need in addition to a player like Mixon to move him??

[Madadamus]

I know Barkley is the #1 dynasty asset. What do we need in addition to a player like Mixon to move him??

A top 5 WR for me, and most teams can’t afford that so he’s usually a guy you aren’t trading.

[honcho55]

I’m more commenting because I’m interested what folks will say. I’d wager I’d rather have the Mixon plus whatever the consensus is than Barkley in most setups. Unless it’s shallow roster 10 man, which I don’t play.

PS: was typing this while above post came in. Would hands down take Mixon and top 5 WR, not close.

[Vcize]

I offered OBJ and Kerryon (pre-OBJ to Cleveland) and it was rejected.