Keenan Trade poll

[bot]

For team in sig. Guy is looking for a WR1. I told myself that this off season I would be patient and only try and trade if I could get good value on my end. I think I can handle the loss of Allen and I feel like Hunt and Kirk could see value bumps in another year or so. I know as a contender I should keep the proven talent bump I like the idea of getting multiple pieces that could see value increases down the road as well.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Why? That team seems to be a strong contender with no weaknesses (at least on offense - dunno much about IDP). Keep Allen and go for a title in 2019.

[ajf235]

Yeah I’d 100% keep Allen here. Hunt, Kirk and the 1.05 are all way too uncertain to gamble away a surefire top 10 WR in his prime.

[Goddard]

Don't really see what you'd be gaining here, other than making your team worse this year.

[IR1]

Maybe in a rebuild, but I'd keep Allen as others have said- solid team, but after the starting 7 rb/wr it starts to get thin

[keebs3]

Adding to the Keenan side. I wouldn't sell for that. It's 3 pieces of potential and maybe's vs. a top tier WR you can win with next year.

[Jigga94]

Keenan by a lot... This poll looks broken

[Titans95]

I think the value is on the hunt side but like others have said KA will help you win THIS year.

It's becoming more and more likely Hunt will be on a team sooner rather than later and the few teams he's already been linked to are dream jobs (Chicago and Philly) so he could easily work his way back into the top 10 RB ranks by 2020. Kirk is a solid piece that's worth a late 1st right now and the 1.05 will net you a top 3 Wr or a top 2 RB.

[JDogil12]

Keenan but I think it's an ok trade

[Goddard]

It's funny how every response has been in favor of Keenan, but the poll has the Hunt side ahead by 2 votes.

[crip7300]

The value is on the Hunt side but like most have said, it probably makes the most sense for your team to keep Allen.

[ajf235]

The value is on the Hunt side but like most have said, it probably makes the most sense for your team to keep Allen.

Is it though? The way I see it is that this trade is the equivalent of two early seconds and a mid-first. I’d imagine KA’s value is at least that of two early firsts in a non-loaded RB class.

[lukkynumber13]

Allen without much hesitation on my part. This all hinges on one's view of Hunt's future of course, which we don't know...

[Gator Sens]

Your team looks really solid. I don't really see the point in gambling on Hunt for this price. I'm not real high on this draft, so the pick does not do much for me based on who you are giving up. I like Kirk a lot as a prospect/moving forward but not for Allen. IF Hunt was a guarantee to play, that would be different.

[saw061600]

It's dynasty but the goal each year should still be to win. Keenan provides better chance for the win than 8 (maybe) weeks of Hunt, Kirk (maybe flex spot) and an unknown asset.