Trade completed

[NY CAT]

Gave: M. Trubisky and Anthony Miller
Rec: J. Rosen and D.J Moore

My other QB is M. Stafford. One Qb starting league

[Dirty Mike&the Boys]

People are probably going to shoot this trade down due to recency bias, but Trubisky just hasn't been impressive. His one game that comes to mind was yesterday against a defense that looks like it would get cooked by my local high school team, and has been getting cooked for 4 weeks now.

It is a pretty even trade, just comes down to preference. Personally, I like Miller far more than Moore, but prefer Rosen over Trubisky. Trade off is that Moore is probably in a better situation than Miller. Regardless, you dont need to start Rosen so you can manage through the growing pains.

[BigBawseRoss]

option #3 = fine.

thats my vote.

[Titans95]

I'd rather have Rosen of Trubisky anyways and I'd rather have Moore long term than Miller even though I really like Miller. You won IMO

[Elroypedro]

Good enough to be an equal trade imo. Definitely not unbalanced. Really none of us know how this will end up so if you both agree it is a win win trade.

[skip]

Voted for the Trubisky side because I've liked him better than most of this class (other than Mayfield) anyway regardless of last night's game.

[Goddard]

In a 1QB league where you already have Stafford, the QBs don't matter. I'd take Moore over Miller.

[skip]

In a 1QB league where you already have Stafford, the QBs don't matter.

I don't agree with this concept. I expect that the owners of Garoppolo, for example, following this strategy aren't terribly happy. Depth of position should not be downplayed.

[hudini33]

It's fine, if you got your guy, nice job.

[darewood11]

In a 1QB league where you already have Stafford, the QBs don't matter.

I don't agree with this concept. I expect that the owners of Garoppolo, for example, following this strategy aren't terribly happy. Depth of position should not be downplayed.

In my 1 qb league dalton flacco and other relevant QBs are on waivers so in that case I agree with this thought process

[dblj1199]

Pretty much in different. You can argue for and against, but a pretty even trade as of right now. It will take a year or two to fully assess this deal.

[hudini33]

In a 1QB league where you already have Stafford, the QBs don't matter.

I don't agree with this concept. I expect that the owners of Garoppolo, for example, following this strategy aren't terribly happy. Depth of position should not be downplayed.

In my 1 qb league dalton flacco and other relevant QBs are on waivers so in that case I agree with this thought process

It depends on league size, but QBs are still relevant

[Goddard]

In a 1QB league where you already have Stafford, the QBs don't matter.

I don't agree with this concept. I expect that the owners of Garoppolo, for example, following this strategy aren't terribly happy. Depth of position should not be downplayed.

I prefer Rosen over Trubisky longterm anyway, so it wouldn't change my vote.