Trade offer on the table. Mike Evans and Sony Michel for Tyreek Hill and Tevin Coleman. Which side you got ?

[UATahoe]

I was really proud of drafting Hill and it’s hard for me to get rid of him but this seems like good value. Thoughts?

[RB6]

Hill side.
Hill=Evans
Coleman>Michel

[BigBawseRoss]

still evans side for me but this is a spicy one. idk why but i trust evans much more than hill on a week to week basis and as his teams primary threat at all times. kc is riddled with talent i feel like it wouldnt be crazy to see hill fade for games at a time if hunt or kelce is hot, and watkins hasnt even gotten going yet (yeah im one of those guys lol)

[Goddard]

This is pretty close. I prefer Hill over Evans, but there's not much of a gap. I also like both Coleman and Michel, but like Michel's upside more. I think Hill and Coleman help you win more in the near future.

[FantasyFoosball]

I own three of the four players in this deal. I own everyone but Evans. I would lean the Hill and Coleman side though. I like Michel better than Coleman, but I like Hill more than Evans, and that's what does it for me. Hill has a way higher ceiling than Evans, and there's no better example of that than this past week. Hill plays in an explosive offense and has a phenomenal rapport with Mahomes. Evans has a high floor but I think his ceiling is definitely capped.

[UATahoe]

I should also mention my league gets punt return and kick return yardage points. Nothing crazy but a few points.

[skip]

In the first 10 or so threads in the advice section there is a thread of Evans or Hill as well as one you already started with Michel or Coleman. Why not yet the answers from both to help you?

[Goddard]

I should also mention my league gets punt return and kick return yardage points. Nothing crazy but a few points.

That makes me like Hill even more.

[Hahaclintondix]

Hill side but close

[Titans95]

i think Evans>=Hill but Michel is worth more than Coleman. IF you would've asked this question last week everyone would be saying Evans is worth more than Hill and if you ask this question when Hill has a bust week people will say Evans. Go with the better long term RB and the more stable targets and TD upside in Evans.

[UATahoe]

I should also mention my league gets punt return and kick return yardage points. Nothing crazy but a few points.

That makes me like Hill even more.

Agreed. I also get a .5 pt and 1 pt bonus for 40 and 50 yard passes.