Which side...Evans or Tyreek

[EAGLES]

Thinking of sending this offer over...thoughts on fairness?

In parentheses is where the rookies were taken in our rookie draft. I’m trying to get another RB with potential/upside since we are expanding our 2nd flex spot next year to include an RB. So, starting in 2019 we will be able to start up to 4 RBs.

Give: Evans/Doctson
Get: Tyreek/Chubb (1.07)/A Miller(2.07)

My Team:
1QB 2RB 3WR 1TE 2Flex 1K 1DEF
12 Teams - 0.5 PPR
QBs: Carr, Tannehill
WRs: Antonio, Evans, K. Allen, Jordy, R. Matthews, Doctson, K. White, Taywan, Kirk (R), TreQuan (R)
RBs: Bell, Penny (R), A. Jones, CJ Prosise, J. White, Gallman, Ekeler, B Scott (R)
TEs: Doyle, Reed, Everett, R. Seals-Jones, J. Butt
DEF: LA RAMs, Saints
K: J. Elliott
2019: 1st, 3rd

[tarantula13]

I definitely like the Tyreek side more, but I'm higher on Tyreek than most and lower on Evans than most. This is also probably Doctson's last year to do something to justify his draft stock. I think all the upside is on the Tyreek side and I would add something to the offer, maybe a 2nd round pick.

[hudini33]

Ya, not sure that gets it done. I like the tyreek side without Miller, so adding him swings it a long ways

[topher]

I like Evans the most here but I’d say you are not giving enough value. Miller may have been drafted at 2.07 but his value for sure has gone way up from that (late 1st, early 2nd I think), you will have to remove him entirely, but I’m not sure it will get done

[Titans95]

I like Evans the most here but I’d say you are not giving enough value. Miller may have been drafted at 2.07 but his value for sure has gone way up from that (late 1st, early 2nd I think), you will have to remove him entirely, but I’m not sure it will get done

This

[notweswelker]

I'd probably take Tyreek alone over Evans Doctson

[Trevormortis]

I'd send it, though it will probably get denied. May have to take one of the 2 out, preferably Miller.

[NFL-ons]

I opened this thinking there might be a debate on Evans vs tyfreak. As much as I want to deny it, I feel they have similar value. Surprised that so much is added to reek side.

[EAGLES]

I wanted to get some insight to this bc I know how much Evans and Hill’s valuations are all over the place. Some devalue Hill due to the Watkins signing and Mahomes and some are really high on Evans. I did think adding Miller was a bit much, but again that’s why I turned here. Looks like I’ll go back to the drawing board

[Space Cowboy]

Love Evans and I agree with the poll results, not close.

[HughHoney]

I prefer Hill over Evans but even if you don’t the gap between Chubb+Miller vs Doctson is huge. Hill side easily.