Nicks or Andre?

[MilwaukeesBest]

In a keeper format non ppr, my likely keepers keepers in sig. Was thinking about offering a trade for Andre but it doesn't feel right. Would probably have to give up Nicks and a player I would be dropping into the pool, or more likely a high draft pick, perhaps both. Just wanted to see what the consensus is out there and if I am over valuing Nicks.

Thx!

[Steelersfan]

Are there any limits on how long you can keep players? If not then I would not pursue AJ and hang on to Nicks for the next 8-10 years...

Good luck!

[Al Kohaul]

Are there any limits on how long you can keep players? If not then I would not pursue AJ and hang on to Nicks for the next 8-10 years...

Good luck!

I agree...keep Nicks

[MilwaukeesBest]

Are there any limits on how long you can keep players? If not then I would not pursue AJ and hang on to Nicks for the next 8-10 years...

Good luck!

There are no limits to keeping the players, thanks for the advice! I love Nicks, just trying to keep my goggles off as an owner. His injury history scares me a bit, but apart from Megatron, there isn't a WR I'd rather own. Just wondering if I'm crazy to think that way...

[Jimi Hendrix]

Are there any limits on how long you can keep players? If not then I would not pursue AJ and hang on to Nicks for the next 8-10 years...

Good luck!

I agree...keep Nicks

[RobertBobson]

Are there any limits on how long you can keep players? If not then I would not pursue AJ and hang on to Nicks for the next 8-10 years...

Good luck!

There are no limits to keeping the players, thanks for the advice! I love Nicks, just trying to keep my goggles off as an owner. His injury history scares me a bit, but apart from Megatron, there isn't a WR I'd rather own. Just wondering if I'm crazy to think that way...

No not really. Nick is pretty much universally valued as a top 5 Wr, as is Nicks. Because you can only keep 4 players, I think Nick's age makes him clearly the superior keeper.


Normally I'd advocate you keeping all three of your WR's, but I just can't cut either of your rbs. Jesus christ that's a strong core.

[MilwaukeesBest]

Thanks, it took 4 years of packaging players to arrive with this core. Just to clarify, I don't own Andre, I was asking whether it would be worth packaging Nicks and a player/pick for him. Thanks so much for the input!