Who Do I Keep? (updated with trades)

[elkoholic08]

The 2017 season is far from over but rosters will soon lock (monday) and it's never too late to start thinking about who will make the cut moving on next year. Essentially my league mandates you keep an entire starting roster and 4 bench. The rest are cut. So not a true dynasty but last year i made the horrible mistake of keeping Smallwood and Keith Marshall over Adam Theilin and Golden Tate.

Anyway my team is in my sig but i think this is in stone: 14 team 1/2 ppr

Qb- Brees
WR- Julio
Wr- Dez
Rb- Kamara
Rb- Mccoy
TE- Henry
Flex- J.Howard
Flex- Arob

Bench 1: Derek Carr
Bench 2: Jamison Crowder ( updated)
Bench 3: Nelson Agholor ( updated)
Bench 4: ?


So I've since traded Foreman and Demarco since this first post and acquired Nelson Agholor

Traded Foreman and a late 2020 first for an early-mid 2019 first
Traded 1.14 and 2.05 for Agholor and 2.03
Traded Demarco for Enunwa straight up

Gives the responses I'd say i have one spot left on my bench now for the following players:

Quincy Enunwa
Cameron Meredith
Paul Richardson
Austin Ekeler



Any help is greatly appreciated. Thank you!

[noahb]

Solid! Hold on to Meredith and Crowder.

[Dirty Mike&the Boys]

I would keep:

D'onta Foreman
Cameron Meredith
Jamison Crowder

[jcc6fd]

Crowder for sure, then I think you could make a case for Murray, Meredith and Foreman. In the end I think I'd land on Crowder, Foreman and Murray. Just think there's enough risk with Meredith coming back and being fantasy relevant and that Murray will be more productive than many anticipate next year.

[Lordchay]

Since it is a 1Qb league and you are already keeping Brees, I wouldn't keep Carr but try to draft another backup QB next year.

I would then keep Meredith, Crowder, Murray & Foreman.

[BigBawseRoss]

The 2017 season is far from over but rosters will soon lock (monday) and it's never too late to start thinking about who will make the cut moving on next year. Essentially my league mandates you keep an entire starting roster and 4 bench. The rest are cut. So not a true dynasty but last year i made the horrible mistake of keeping Smallwood and Keith Marshall over Adam Theilin and Golden Tate.

Anyway my team is in my sig but i think this is in stone: 14 team 1/2 ppr

Qb- Brees
WR- Julio
Wr- Dez
Rb- Kamara
Rb- Mccoy
TE- Henry
Flex- J.Howard
Flex- Arob

Bench 1: Derek Carr
Bench 2: ?
Bench 3: ?
Bench 4: ?

So I have 3 spots left and have the following to choose from:
Demarco Murray
Jamison Crowder
Austin Ekeler
D'onta Foreman
Cameron Meredith

Any help is greatly appreciated. Thank you!

i cant get beyond this part. idk what took place that would have led you to make that bad of a decision

[hockeyBjj]

The 2017 season is far from over but rosters will soon lock (monday) and it's never too late to start thinking about who will make the cut moving on next year. Essentially my league mandates you keep an entire starting roster and 4 bench. The rest are cut. So not a true dynasty but last year i made the horrible mistake of keeping Smallwood and Keith Marshall over Adam Theilin and Golden Tate.

Anyway my team is in my sig but i think this is in stone: 14 team 1/2 ppr

Qb- Brees
WR- Julio
Wr- Dez
Rb- Kamara
Rb- Mccoy
TE- Henry
Flex- J.Howard
Flex- Arob

Bench 1: Derek Carr
Bench 2: ?
Bench 3: ?
Bench 4: ?

So I have 3 spots left and have the following to choose from:
Demarco Murray
Jamison Crowder
Austin Ekeler
D'onta Foreman
Cameron Meredith

Any help is greatly appreciated. Thank you!

i cant get beyond this part. idk what took place that would have led you to make that bad of a decision

People were not high on Thielen last year as they should have been across the board. It wasn't just him by any means

[elkoholic08]

The 2017 season is far from over but rosters will soon lock (monday) and it's never too late to start thinking about who will make the cut moving on next year. Essentially my league mandates you keep an entire starting roster and 4 bench. The rest are cut. So not a true dynasty but last year i made the horrible mistake of keeping Smallwood and Keith Marshall over Adam Theilin and Golden Tate.

Anyway my team is in my sig but i think this is in stone: 14 team 1/2 ppr

Qb- Brees
WR- Julio
Wr- Dez
Rb- Kamara
Rb- Mccoy
TE- Henry
Flex- J.Howard
Flex- Arob

Bench 1: Derek Carr
Bench 2: ?
Bench 3: ?
Bench 4: ?

So I have 3 spots left and have the following to choose from:
Demarco Murray
Jamison Crowder
Austin Ekeler
D'onta Foreman
Cameron Meredith

Any help is greatly appreciated. Thank you!

i cant get beyond this part. idk what took place that would have led you to make that bad of a decision

So i spent a first round pick on Keith Marshall and he didnt play at all so i still had hope. I also had awful RB's (i didnt have kamara and howard at this point) so i needed to hope one of them panned out.

Also I didnt buy into the Theilin hype since Diggs was coming back and i thought he was just a flash in the pan.... It happens...

[gunzwil guinea pigs]

foreman, crowder, meredith since your team is pretty good at RB

[cvbuc]

Foreman, Crowder

Then a tossup on Meredith and Murray.
I know he's 30, but every time we try to bury Demarco... Demarco rises back up.

[elkoholic08]

So i traded Foreman and a late 2020 first for an early 2019 first and also traded for Agholor

So I'll keep Carr, Crowder, Agholor


Now between Meredith and DeMarco...

[ddog2303]

I wouldn’t even considering keeping Murray. I’d rather take my chances on Meredith. Murray is on the wrong side of 30, had injuries all season long and he’s likely going to be out of TEN. The odds of Murray signing somewhere and being a factor are slim. To me, Meredith is the easy choice.

[Goddard]

I would keep:

D'onta Foreman
Cameron Meredith
Jamison Crowder

These are the 3 I'd hold as well.

[thomasscheeks]

Foreman, Crowder and Meredith

[elkoholic08]

Foreman, Crowder and Meredith

So i updated the OP, have since traded foreman and demarco and have acquired Agholor and Enunwa. Learning to keeping the 3 of

Crowder
Agholor
Enunwa.