Which pair of studs would you rather have?

[LaFleur42]

For team 1 below, looking to make some moves. Want to get rid of some of the old guys (Brady, AJ, and DT), but received an offer to deal Kamara and Davis for Keenan and Melvin. I love me some Kamara and would hate to be parting ways, but is this just too good to pass up?

[prinefan]

Kamara/Davis for me. I do believe in Davis' future production. Actually prefer them by a decent bit. And LOOOVE Kamara.

[RB6]

Kamara side. I'm not a Gordon believer.

[lukkynumber13]

I view Gordon and Kamara as similar assets from a future production standpoint, and I would definitely take Allen over Davis.

[ravn88]

I view Gordon and Kamara as similar assets from a future production standpoint, and I would definitely take Allen over Davis.

x2

[NY CAT]

I like the two young guns. Success is theirs for the taking. Kamara was sensational this year sharing with Ingram.
Gordon seems to be a volume back.

Davis rapport with Mariota hopefully will improve.

Keenan is a beast however, father time is catching up on P. Rivers.

[Goddard]

I can see the allure of the young guys, but give me Keenan and Gordon. The gap between the WRs is much larger than that of the RBs (if any).

[dchurch85]

I can see the allure of the young guys, but give me Keenan and Gordon. The gap between the WRs is much larger than that of the RBs (if any).

These are my thoughts.

[JIBaseball04]

I'd take the Keenan and Melvin side. Even though Kamara is definitely legit and Davis was a high NFL draft pick with plenty of talent, I'd rather have the two proven high-end producers who are in their prime.

[Blackout]

Gordon volume and production are big enough to close the gap with Kamara (if there is any gap). And i'd rather have Keenan for now.

But would definitely understand Kamara's appeal. Whatever you do won't be a bad choice anyway.

[RBlivesmatter]

I’d keep Kamara and Davis, Davis should have a full healthy preseason which will help his chemistry with Mariota and Kamara will get more work next year IMO, Payton never liked Ingram
Love allen and gordon but don’t like having two studs from the same team. Especially with rivers getting older

[esloan35]

Kamara and Davis for me. I don't think the Kamara season was a fluke and he will continue to be a stud for a long time. Davis is a freak athlete who is ready to bust out. Good luck.. Either side of this deal is nice.

[gunzwil guinea pigs]

I can see the allure of the young guys, but give me Keenan and Gordon. The gap between the WRs is much larger than that of the RBs (if any).

x2